Discrimination and Disrespect

Author:
  • BEBenjamin Eidelson
    Benjamin Eidelson

Abstract
Discrimination, this book argues, is a form of differential treatment distinguished by its special connection to the differential ascription of some property to different people. This simple conceptual analysis of discrimination dissolves certain recurrent puzzles. It also positions us to reconsider the derivative notion of indirect discrimination (or discrimination consisting in “disparate impact”). Offering a revisionist account of that idea, the book explains why some such cases are reducible to “direct” discrimination, and why others, although morally and legally suspect, may not best be thought of as “discrimination” at all. The core of the book then argues that what makes some cases of discrimination intrinsically wrongful is that they manifest an attitude of disrespect for the personhood of those who are disfavored. The book specifies what this attitude consists in, and demonstrates how attending to its character illuminates different forms of wrongful discrimination. Focusing on the distinct requirements of respect for the equality and autonomy of persons in turn, the book explains why we condemn some cases of discrimination as strongly as we do and offers principles to guide our thinking where we are less certain. The book concludes with an extended discussion of racial profiling in law enforcement. Although profiling may not itself effectuate an attitude of basic disrespect, it contributes to a set of contingent social understandings that undermine the conditions of mutual respect. The failure to clearly separate these two lines of criticism, the book argues, has confounded popular and philosophical discussion of profiling and similar practices.