Financial literacy is widely expected to improve investment decisions, yet evidence that financial knowledge translates into economically optimal behavior remains surprisingly limited. We examine the relationship between financial literacy and cost-minimizing allocation in a framed field experiment. A screened sample of financially literate U.S. adults allocates an incentivized hypothetical portfolio between two index funds that track the same benchmark but differ in expense ratios and historical returns. The funds offer equivalent expected pre-fee returns, so allocating to the lower fee fund is the normatively preferred choice. Contrary to this expectation, higher scores on the FINRA financial literacy assessment are associated with smaller allocations to the lower fee fund. Participants with higher literacy scores are also less likely to split their portfolios equally; however, movement away from equal allocation is concentrated toward the fund with stronger historical returns and higher fees. Thus, within an already financially literate sample, greater measured knowledge is associated with more decisive allocation but not with greater cost minimization. Knowing a financial principle is not the same as recognizing when it applies.