How (not) to organize sports arbitration: Montenegrin olympic committee arbitration, autonomy, and the rule of law
Open Access
- 10 November 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in The International Sports Law Journal
- Vol. 26 (2) , 130-145
Abstract
Arbitration under the auspices of sport bodies and Olympic committees is a popular mechanism globally, and one that aligns well with both the ideals of safeguarding sport from inappropriate influences and offering speedy and cost-effective dispute resolution. But it is by no means exempt from problems or situations where it cannot perform such a beneficial role. Montenegrin Olympic Committee (MOC) Arbitration offers a case study on how not to organize sport arbitration. Set within the background of deeper sports governance issues in Montenegro, MOC Arbitration exhibits total autonomy from the wider arbitral legal framework and a series of issues concerning arbitrators, challenges and remedies against awards that render the mechanism practically unworkable. Such a state of affairs, apart from being an affront to the rule of law, is deeply detrimental to interests of sportspeople and potentially further exacerbates governance issues. Aiming to help promote effective (sports) arbitration mechanisms more generally, the present article dissects the critical issues with the MOC Arbitration and provides some guidance on how to secure a workable mechanism that respects the needs and dignity of sportspeople under its jurisdiction.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Responsible sport and state oversight: sports organisations as civil society organisations and private regulators in France and GermanyThe International Sports Law Journal, 2023
- Requiring good governance from private regulators: what about the rest of us after ESL and ISU?The International Sports Law Journal, 2023
- Down with the politics, up with the law! Reinforcing EU law’s supervision of sport autonomy in EuropeThe International Sports Law Journal, 2023
- Independence and impartiality of sports disputes resolution in the UKThe International Sports Law Journal, 2021
- Mandatory arbitration as a possible future for sports arbitration: the Portuguese exampleThe International Sports Law Journal, 2020
- The extraordinary autonomy of sports bodies under Swiss law: lessons to be drawnThe International Sports Law Journal, 2019
- Good governance in Sport: comparative law aspectsThe International Sports Law Journal, 2019
- Domestic sports arbitration in Turkey: creating a sui generis sporting jurisdictional order Alla TurcaThe International Sports Law Journal, 2017
- Protecting Athletes’ Right to a Fair Trial Through EU Competition Law: The Pechstein Case2015
- Arbitration clauses in sport governing bodies’ statutes: consent or constraint? Analysis from the perspective of Article 6(1) of the European Convention on Human RightsThe International Sports Law Journal, 2013