Methodological Proposal to Resolve the Dichotomy between Improving Energy Efficiency and Preserving Heritage—Case Study: Brutalist Built Heritage
Open Access
Abstract
The debate about how to conduct energy interventions in built heritage remains open. At present, the various European and national regulations allow the absence of energy intervention in cases where the character of a building with recognized heritage value would be jeopardized. This situation means that heritage preservation and energy improvement are divided into two airtight and unconnected blocs. It is possible and necessary to break that dichotomy by taking steps that enable both blocs to interrelate. Based on a methodology previously proposed by the authors to regulate changes in the urban landscape due to the rehabilitation of residential building façades, as a novel aspect, this article proposes taking a further step in the methodological process. Several criteria to balance the level of energy intervention for all buildings are thus introduced, according to the urban and architectural characteristics of each building, irrespective of their use and degree of protection. It is concluded that such a balance is possible when certain indicators are used and when determined action criteria are applied. However, one of the architectural characteristics more susceptible to being affected when undertaking an energy intervention on a building’s thermal enclosure is the materiality, which becomes especially important in the case of brutalist architecture with reinforced concrete, one of its most identifying features, giving it a specific personality. That architectural movement was therefore chosen for a case study, applying the proposed methodology to three brutalist buildings in the area of San Sebastián, Spain.Keywords
This publication has 7 references indexed in Scilit:
- Energy Efficiency versus Heritage—Proposal for a Replicable Prototype to Maintain the Architectural Values of Buildings in Energy Improvement Interventions on Facades: The Case of the Expansion of San SebastiánCoatings, 2024
- SUSTAINABLE RETROFITTING STRATEGIES FOR CULTURALLY SIGNIFICANT BRUTALIST BUILDINGS: ENERGY-EFFICIENT STRATEGIES FOR A HIGH-RISE RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX IN SARAJEVO, BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINAJournal of Green Building, 2024
- A Methodology to Regulate Transformation of a City’s Appearance Due to Energy Efficiency Building Renovations: A Case Study: Errenteria (Spain)Heritage, 2023
- State of Preservation and Intervention Proposal in a Modern Architecture Building: The Auditorium of the Labor University of Cheste, SpainJournal of Performance of Constructed Facilities, 2023
- Vulnerability and vulnerable groups from an intersectionality perspectiveInternational Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2020
- External Insulation Systems for Buildings with Complex Façades in Urban Historic Centers2019
- Concrete and council housingCity, 2018