Race and Gender Bias in Clerkship Grading
- 19 June 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Teaching and Learning in Medicine
- Vol. 36 (3) , 304-311
Abstract
Phenomenon: Existing literature, as well as anecdotal evidence, suggests that tiered clinical grading systems may display systematic demographic biases. This study aimed to investigate these potential inequities in-depth. Specifically, this study attempted to address the following gaps in the literature: (1) studying grades actually assigned to students (as opposed to self-reported ones), (2) using longitudinal data over an 8-year period, providing stability of data, (3) analyzing three important, potentially confounding covariates, (4) using a comprehensive multivariate statistical design, and (5) investigating not just the main effects of gender and race, but also their potential interaction. Approach: Participants included 1,905 graduates (985 women, 51.7%) who received the Doctor of Medicine degree between 2014 and 2021. Most of the participants were white (n = 1,310, 68.8%) and about one-fifth were nonwhite (n = 397, 20.8%). There were no reported race data for 10.4% (n = 198). To explore potential differential grading, a two-way multivariate analysis of covariance was employed to examine the impact of race and gender on grades in eight required clerkships, adjusting for prior academic performance. Findings: There were two significant main effects, race and gender, but no interaction effect between gender and race. Women received higher grades on average on all eight clerkships, and white students received higher grades on average on four of the eight clerkships (Medicine, Pediatrics, Surgery, Obstetrics/Gynecology). These relationships held even when accounting for prior performance covariates. Insights: These findings provide additional evidence that tiered grading systems may be subject to systematic demographic biases. It is difficult to tease apart the contributions of various factors to the observed differences in gender and race on clerkship grades, and the interactions that produce these biases may be quite complex. The simplest solution to cut through the tangled web of grading biases may be to move away from a tiered grading system altogether.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Science faculty’s subtle gender biases favor male studentsProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2012
- Variation and Imprecision of Clerkship Grading in U.S. Medical SchoolsAcademic Medicine, 2012
- Can Medical School Performance Predict Residency Performance? Resident Selection and Predictors of Successful Performance in Obstetrics and GynecologyJournal of Graduate Medical Education, 2010
- Gender Stereotypes Are Alive, Well, and Busy Producing Workplace DiscriminationIndustrial and Organizational Psychology, 2008
- The Science of Sex Differences in Science and MathematicsPsychological Science in the Public Interest, 2007
- The Predictive Validity of the MCAT for Medical School Performance and Medical Board Licensing Examinations: A Meta-Analysis of the Published ResearchAcademic Medicine, 2007
- A preliminary study of emotional intelligence, empathy and exam performance in first year medical studentsPersonality and Individual Differences, 2005
- Teachers, Race, and Student Achievement in a Randomized ExperimentReview of Economics and Statistics, 2004
- Description and Prescription: How Gender Stereotypes Prevent Women's Ascent Up the Organizational LadderJournal of Social Issues, 2001
- Effect of student and preceptor gender on clinical grades in an ambulatory care clerkshipAcademic Medicine, 1995