The impact of overdiagnosis on the selection of efficient lung cancer screening strategies
Authors:
Open Access
- 10 January 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in International Journal of Cancer
- Vol. 140 (11) , 2436-2443
Abstract
The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) recently updated their national lung screening guidelines and recommended low‐dose computed tomography (LDCT) for lung cancer (LC) screening through age 80. However, the risk of overdiagnosis among older populations is a concern. Using four comparative models from the Cancer Intervention and Surveillance Modeling Network, we evaluate the overdiagnosis of the screening program recommended by USPSTF in the U.S. 1950 birth cohort. We estimate the number of LC deaths averted by screening (D) per overdiagnosed case (O), yielding the ratio D/O, to quantify the trade‐off between the harms and benefits of LDCT. We analyze 576 hypothetical screening strategies that vary by age, smoking, and screening frequency and evaluate efficient screening strategies that maximize the D/O ratio and other metrics including D and life‐years gained (LYG) per overdiagnosed case. The estimated D/O ratio for the USPSTF screening program is 2.85 (model range: 1.5–4.5) in the 1950 birth cohort, implying LDCT can prevent ∼3 LC deaths per overdiagnosed case. This D/O ratio increases by 22% when the program stops screening at an earlier age 75 instead of 80. Efficiency frontier analysis shows that while the most efficient screening strategies that maximize the mortality reduction (D) irrespective of overdiagnosis screen through age 80, screening strategies that stop at age 75 versus 80 produce greater efficiency in increasing life‐years gained per overdiagnosed case. Given the risk of overdiagnosis with LC screening, the stopping age of screening merits further consideration when balancing benefits and harms.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Reality Check for Overdiagnosis Estimates Associated With Breast Cancer ScreeningJNCI: Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 2014
- Screening for Lung Cancer: U.S. Preventive Services Task Force Recommendation StatementAnnals of Internal Medicine, 2014
- Comparative analysis of 5 lung cancer natural history and screening models that reproduce outcomes of the NLST and PLCO trialsCancer, 2014
- Comparative Effectiveness of Alternative Prostate-Specific Antigen–Based Prostate Cancer Screening StrategiesAnnals of Internal Medicine, 2013
- The benefits and harms of breast cancer screening: an independent reviewThe Lancet, 2012
- Chapter 4: Development of the Counterfactual Smoking Histories Used to Assess the Effects of Tobacco ControlRisk Analysis, 2012
- Overdiagnosis in CancerJNCI: Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 2010
- Evaluating Test Strategies for Colorectal Cancer Screening: A Decision Analysis for the U.S. Preventive Services Task ForceAnnals of Internal Medicine, 2008
- Identification of small lung nodules at autopsy: implications for lung cancer screening and overdiagnosis biasLung Cancer, 2001
- The current status of postoperative complications and risk factors after a pulmonary resection for primary lung cancer A multivariate analysisEuropean Journal of Cardio-Thoracic Surgery, 1997