EFFECTIVENESS OF POLICY LEVEL ENVIRONMENTAL AND SUSTAINABILITY ASSESSMENT: CHALLENGES AND LESSONS FROM RECENT PRACTICE
- 1 March 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by World Scientific Pub Co Pte Ltd in Journal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management
- Vol. 13 (01) , 39-65
Abstract
This paper explores the challenges and lessons from recent practice and experience of applying tools such as Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) and Sustainability Appraisal at the policy level in the UK and Europe. It investigates whether or not these tools have been effective and helped to deliver more sustainable development at the high level of national policy development. The analysis is illustrated by case examples from the UK, such as Eco-towns and Energy Planning. The paper concludes that the current performance by the UK Government in implementing the SEA Directive for national level strategic actions is far from exemplary. At the root of the problem is the poor consideration and evaluation of reasonable alternatives, the fundamentally weak conception of sustainability adopted and the apparent perception that having to undertake an assessment and comply with the SEA Directive is a hurdle, rather than a useful mechanism for helping to deliver better and more sustainable evidence-based policy making.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Evaluating the effectiveness of impact assessment instruments: Theorising the nature and implications of their political constitutionEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review, 2010
- Reviewing the quality of strategic environmental assessment reports for English spatial plan core strategiesEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review, 2010
- Introduction: The effectiveness of impact assessment instrumentsImpact Assessment and Project Appraisal, 2009
- Rationalising the Policy Mess? Ex Ante Policy Assessment and the Utilisation of Knowledge in the Policy ProcessEnvironment and Planning A: Economy and Space, 2009
- WHAT APPEARS TO MAKE SEA EFFECTIVE IN DIFFERENT PLANNING SYSTEMSJournal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management, 2008
- A research agenda for data and scale issues in Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA)Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 2007
- BEYOND THE PILLARS: SUSTAINABILITY ASSESSMENT AS A FRAMEWORK FOR EFFECTIVE INTEGRATION OF SOCIAL, ECONOMIC AND ECOLOGICAL CONSIDERATIONS IN SIGNIFICANT DECISION-MAKINGJournal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management, 2006
- SEA effectiveness criteria—equally valid in all countries? The case of ItalyEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review, 2006
- HAVING AN IMPACT? CONTEXT ELEMENTS FOR EFFECTIVE SEA APPLICATION IN TRANSPORT POLICY, PLAN AND PROGRAMME MAKINGJournal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management, 2005
- Rationality in decision- and policy-making: implications for strategic environmental assessmentImpact Assessment and Project Appraisal, 2000