The Labor Theory of Value and Simple Commodity Production
Author:
- 1 October 2007
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Science & Society: A Journal of Marxist Thought and Analysis
- Vol. 71 (4) , 455-483
Abstract
Marx once characterized the economy of the North American colonies as one of simple commodity production. Historical research shows that simple commodity production there was a type of “moral economy” in which the labor theory of value fails to explain the market prices at which commodities exchange. This should not surprise; the “law of value” and the labor theory are theoretically suited to explain exchange ratios only in capitalism and in no other mode, historical or hypothetical. The first three chapters of Capital therefore explicate the labor theory in the context of a capitalist economy and not, as many interpreters of Marx have it, in the context of simple commodity production. Yet Marx elsewhere applies the “law of value” to precapitalist economies, including simple commodity production, thus engaging in an apparent contradiction. This inconsistency only disappears if he is read “dialectically” — with a heady dose of Hegelian teleology. This, however, comes at the considerable cost of substituting metaphysical for scientific explanation. The Analytical Marxists’ aim of expunging Hegelian influences from historical materialism thus appears to be justified.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Recent Developments in the Labor Theory of ValueReview of Radical Political Economics, 2000
- Liberal Theory and the Idea of Communist JusticeAmerican Political Science Review, 1998
- Private Property versus Markets: Democratic and Communitarian Critiques of CapitalismAmerican Political Science Review, 1997
- Putting "Capitalism" in Its Place: A Review of Recent LiteratureThe William and Mary Quarterly, 1995
- Karl Marx on the transition from feudalism to capitalismTheory and Society, 1993
- Self-Sufficiency and the Agricultural Economy of Eighteenth-Century MassachusettsThe William and Mary Quarterly, 1984
- The Independent Mode of ProductionReview of Radical Political Economics, 1979
- Alienation and Justice in the MarketAmerican Political Science Review, 1978
- CASH IS GOOD TO EAT: SELF-SUFFICIENCY AND EXCHANGE IN THE RURAL ECONOMY OF THE UNITED STATESRadical History Review, 1977
- Karl Marx and Enclosures in EnglandReview of Radical Political Economics, 1974