In Reply Dr Merz claims that we understated the “precedential value” of the Nuremberg Code on the common law development of the “legal duty” of medical scientists to secure informed consent. Our Viewpoint made clear that the Code has been a “milestone in the history of biomedical research ethics” and has served as an important “guideline” for courts in the United States and possibly in other countries, but we also stated that the Code has not been adopted by any government, “with the partial exception of the US Department of Defense in 1953 regarding defensive experiments concerning atomic, biological, and chemical agents.”