A re-examination of the effects of biased lineup instructions in eyewitness identification.
- 1 October 2005
- journal article
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Law and Human Behavior
- Vol. 29 (5) , 575-604
Abstract
A meta-analytic review of research comparing biased and unbiased instructions in eyewitness identification experiments showed an asymmetry; specifically, that biased instructions led to a large and consistent decrease in accuracy in target-absent lineups, but produced inconsistent results for target-present lineups, with an average effect size near zero (Steblay, 1997). The results for target-present lineups are surprising, and are inconsistent with statistical decision theories (i.e., Green & Swets, 1966). A re-examination of the relevant studies and the meta-analysis of those studies shows clear evidence that correct identification rates do increase with biased lineup instructions, and that biased witnesses make correct identifications at a rate considerably above chance. Implications for theory, as well as police procedure and policy, are discussed.Keywords
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- A memory and decision model for eyewitness identificationApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2003
- Social influence in eyewitness recall: A meta-analytic review of lineup instruction effects.Law and Human Behavior, 1997
- Distinguishing accurate from inaccurate eyewitness identifications via inquiries about decision processes.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1994
- Selection of lineup foils by similarity to the suspect is likely to misfire.Law and Human Behavior, 1992
- Biased lineups: Sequential presentation reduces the problem.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1991
- The external validity of eyewitness identification research: Generalizing across subject populations.Law and Human Behavior, 1989
- Improving the reliability of eyewitness identification: Putting context into context.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1987
- The reliability of eyewitness identification: The role of system and estimator variables.Law and Human Behavior, 1987
- Realism and eyewitness identification research.Law and Human Behavior, 1980
- Strength theory and recognition memory.Journal of Experimental Psychology, 1972