The (Non-)Status of ‘Duldung’: Non-Deportability in Germany and the Politics of Limitless Temporariness
- 15 November 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Refugee Studies
- Vol. 36 (3) , 409-429
Abstract
One of the ways in which states deal with the issue of non-deportability is limbo-statuses. This article examines the German status of Duldung (toleration) as a case study, which stands out in international comparison for its longevity and its broad administrative application. Based on a comprehensive study of federal policy on Duldung and accompanying political discourses starting from 1962 until 2019, it presents an in-depth analysis of the shifts and continuities in the policies of Duldung in Germany. In the trajectory of the Duldung status, I identify its different functions for German national migration policy, thereby revisiting explanations offered by Böcker and Vogel on the existence of residential limbo-statuses. I conclude that Duldung presents a flexible tool to integrate conflicting policy interests, specifically economic interests, while maintaining a policy of disenfranchisement that characterizes Duldung as an instrument of deterrence. Ultimately, I offer a critique of the exclusionary character of Duldung, rooted in the fiction of temporary stay.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Migrationsmanagement: Praktiken, Intentionen, Interventionen (Editorial)Journal für Entwicklungspolitik, 2017
- The Rule of Law and the Right to StayPolitics & Society, 2014
- II. KRÄFTEVERHÄLTNISSE IN DER BUNDESDEUTSCHEN MIGRATIONSPOLITIK2014
- Asylum and the Expansion of Deportation in the United KingdomGovernment and Opposition, 2008
- The Limits of Unilateral Migration Control: Deportation and Inter-state CooperationGovernment and Opposition, 2008
- Coercive Capacity and The Politics of ImplementationComparative Political Studies, 2005
- Stratifizierte Rechte und soziale Exklusion von Migranten im Wohlfahrtsstaat / Stratified Rights and Social Exclusion of Migrants in the Welfare StateZeitschrift Fur Soziologie, 2005
- Methodische Aspekte der Diskursanalyse. Probleme der Analyse diskursiver Auseinandersetzungen am Beispiel der deutschen Diskussion über den Kosovokrieg2003
- Migrant “Illegality” and Deportability in Everyday LifeAnnual Review of Anthropology, 2002
- Why Liberal States Accept Unwanted ImmigrationWorld Politics, 1997