Majority representation and legitimacy: Survey-experimental evidence from the European Union
Open Access
- 15 January 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in European Journal of Political Research
- Vol. 62 (1) , 285-307
Abstract
What can policy makers do in day-to-day decision making to strengthen citizens' belief that the political system is legitimate? Much literature has highlighted that the realization of citizens' personal preferences in policy making is an important driver of legitimacy beliefs. We argue that citizens, in addition, also care about whether a policy represents the preferences of the majority of citizens, even if their personal preference diverges from the majority's. Using the case of the European Union (EU) as a system that has recurringly experienced crises of public legitimacy, we conduct a vignette survey experiment in which respondents assess the legitimacy of fictitious EU decisions that vary in how they were taken and whose preferences they represent. Results from original surveys conducted in the five largest EU countries show that the congruence of EU decisions not only with personal opinion but also with different forms of majority opinion significantly strengthens legitimacy beliefs. We also show that the most likely mechanism behind this finding is the application of a ‘consensus heuristic’, by which respondents use majority opinion as a cue to identify legitimate decisions. In contrast, procedural features such as the consultation of interest groups or the inclusiveness of decision making in the institutions have little effect on legitimacy beliefs. These findings suggest that policy makers can address legitimacy deficits by strengthening majority representation, which will have both egotropic and sociotropic effects.Keywords
Funding Information
- Fritz Thyssen Stiftung (20.16.0.045WW)
This publication has 52 references indexed in Scilit:
- Which decision‐making arrangements generate the strongest legitimacy beliefs? Evidence from a randomised field experimentEuropean Journal of Political Research, 2012
- Democracy and Legitimacy in the European Union Revisited: Input, Output and ‘Throughput’Political Studies, 2012
- Input and output legitimacy: synergy or trade-off? Empirical evidence from an EU surveyJournal of European Public Policy, 2010
- Does Descriptive Race Representation Enhance Institutional Legitimacy? The Case of the U.S. CourtsThe Journal of Politics, 2010
- Narrowing the Legitimacy Gap: Turnovers as a Cause of Democratic ConsolidationThe Journal of Politics, 2009
- Educating the Least Informed: Group Endorsements in a Grassroots CampaignAmerican Journal of Political Science, 2009
- Competing Models of EU Legitimacy: the Test of Popular Expectations*JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies, 2008
- The meaning and measure of state legitimacy: Results for 72 countriesEuropean Journal of Political Research, 2006
- Response Latency Methodology for Survey Research: Measurement and Modeling StrategiesPolitical Analysis, 2003
- Audience response as a heuristic cue in persuasion.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1987