Uses of expertise: sources, quotes, and voice in the reporting of genetics in the news
Author:
- 1 October 1999
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Public Understanding of Science
- Vol. 8 (4) , 285-302
Abstract
Science journalists call upon experts for background and for clarification and comment on scientific findings. This paper examines how science writers choose and use experts, and it focuses on several cases of reporting about genetics and behavior. Our research included two sources of data: interviews with 15 science reporters and three print media samples of coverage of genetics and behavior—alcoholism (between 1980-1995), homosexuality (in 1993 and 1995), and mental illness (between 1970-1995). Science reporters seek relevant and specific experts for nearly every story. Good sources are knowledgeable, are connected to prestigious institutions, are direct and articulate and don't overqualify statements, and they return phone calls. The mean number of experts quoted was 2.8 per story, differing for alcoholism (3.5), homosexuality (2.8), and mental illness (2.6). Researchers and scientists predominated among experts quoted. Quotes were used to provide context, give legitimization, as explication, to provide a kind of balance, and to outline implications. For the homosexuality sample, a significantly greater percentage of activists and advocates were quoted (21 percent compared with 5 percent and 1 percent in other samples, X 2 < 0.0001). “Lay” quotes for alcoholism and mental illness were minimal. Except for homosexuality, whose advocates are organized, those “affected” do not have a voice in genetics news stories.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Sources in science: who can we trust?The Lancet, 1996
- Reporting research in medical journals and newspapersBMJ, 1995
- The interaction of journalists and scientific experts: co-operation and conflict between two professional culturesMedia, Culture & Society, 1995
- Medical journalists and expert sources on medicinesPublic Understanding of Science, 1994
- Journalistic practices and science reporting in the British pressPublic Understanding of Science, 1994
- News Sources and News Context: The Effect of Routine News, Conflict and ProximityJournalism Quarterly, 1993
- The meaning of `public understanding of science' in the United States after World War IIPublic Understanding of Science, 1992
- The role of the mass media in scientific controversy1987
- The Credible Scientific SourceJournalism Quarterly, 1987
- Art As Collective ActionAmerican Sociological Review, 1974