Genomic Selection for Any Dairy Breeding Program via Optimized Investment in Phenotyping and Genotyping
Open Access
- 10 February 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Genetics
- Vol. 12
Abstract
This paper evaluates the potential of maximizing genetic gain in dairy cattle breeding by optimizing investment into phenotyping and genotyping. Conventional breeding focuses on phenotyping selection candidates or their close relatives to maximize selection accuracy for breeders and quality assurance for producers. Genomic selection decoupled phenotyping and selection and through this increased genetic gain per year compared to the conventional selection. Although genomic selection is established in well-resourced breeding programs, small populations and developing countries still struggle with the implementation. The main issues include the lack of training animals and lack of financial resources. To address this, we simulated a case-study of a small dairy population with a number of scenarios with equal available resources yet varied use of resources for phenotyping and genotyping. The conventional progeny testing scenario collected 11 phenotypic records per lactation. In genomic selection scenarios, we reduced phenotyping to between 10 and 1 phenotypic records per lactation and invested the saved resources into genotyping. We tested these scenarios at different relative prices of phenotyping to genotyping and with or without an initial training population for genomic selection. Reallocating a part of phenotyping resources for repeated milk records to genotyping increased genetic gain compared to the conventional selection scenario regardless of the amount and relative cost of phenotyping, and the availability of an initial training population. Genetic gain increased by increasing genotyping, despite reduced phenotyping. High-genotyping scenarios even saved resources. Genomic selection scenarios expectedly increased accuracy for young non-phenotyped candidate males and females, but also proven females. This study shows that breeding programs should optimize investment into phenotyping and genotyping to maximize return on investment. Our results suggest that any dairy breeding program using conventional progeny testing with repeated milk records can implement genomic selection without increasing the level of investment.Keywords
All Related Versions
Funding Information
- Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council
- University of Edinburgh
- The Slovenian Research and Innovation Agency
This publication has 52 references indexed in Scilit:
- Resource Allocation for Maximizing Prediction Accuracy and Genetic Gain of Genomic Selection in Plant Breeding: A Simulation ExperimentG3: Genes, Genomes, Genetics, 2013
- Genomic selection requires genomic control of inbreedingGenetics Selection Evolution, 2012
- Response to genomic selection: The Bulmer effect and the potential of genomic selection when the number of phenotypic records is limitingGenetics Selection Evolution, 2012
- Assessment of alternative genotyping strategies to maximize imputation accuracy at minimal costGenetics Selection Evolution, 2012
- The value of cows in reference populations for genomic selection of new functional traitsAnimal, 2012
- Persistence of accuracy of genomic estimated breeding values over generations in layer chickensGenetics Selection Evolution, 2011
- Different models of genetic variation and their effect on genomic evaluationGenetics Selection Evolution, 2011
- Accuracy of Predicting the Genetic Risk of Disease Using a Genome-Wide ApproachPLOS ONE, 2008
- Prediction of lactation milk yield using various milk recording methods2008
- Accuracy of predicting milk yield from alternative milk recording schemesAnimal Science, 2005