A comparative analysis of 21 literature search engines
Preprint
- 22 July 2008
- preprint
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Precedings
- p. 1
Abstract
With increasing number of bibliographic software, scientists and health professionals either make a subjective choice of tool(s) that could suit their needs or face a challenge of analyzing multiple features of a plethora of search programs. There is an urgent need for a thorough comparative analysis of the available bio-literature scanning tools, from the user’s perspective. We report results of the first time semi-quantitative comparison of 21 programs, which can search published (partial or full text) documents in life science areas. The observations can assist life science researchers and medical professionals to make an informed selection among the programs, depending on their search objectives. Some of the important findings are: 1. Most of the hits obtained from Scopus, ReleMed, EBImed, CiteXplore, and HighWire Press were usually relevant (i.e. these tools show a better precision than other tools). 2. But a very high number of relevant citations were retrieved by HighWire Press, Google Scholar, CiteXplore and Pubmed Central (they had better recall). 3. HWP and CiteXplore seemed to have a good balance of precision and recall efficiencies. 4. PubMed Central, PubMed and Scopus provided the most useful query systems. 5. GoPubMed, BioAsk, EBIMed, ClusterMed could be more useful among the tools that can automatically process the retrieved citations for further scanning of bio-entities such as proteins, diseases, tissues, molecular interactions, etc. The authors suggest the use of PubMed, Scopus, Google Scholar and HighWire Press - for better coverage, and GoPubMed - to view the hits categorized based on the MeSH and gene ontology terms. The article is relavant to all life science subjects.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- PubMed vs. HighWire Press: A head-to-head comparison of two medical literature search enginesComputers in Biology and Medicine, 2007
- EBIMed—text crunching to gather facts for proteins from MedlineBioinformatics, 2007
- Text similarity: an alternative way to search MEDLINEBioinformatics, 2006
- Protein annotation by EBIMedNature Biotechnology, 2006
- Literature mining for the biologist: from information retrieval to biological discoveryNature Reviews Genetics, 2006
- PubMed Assistant: a biologist-friendly interface for enhanced PubMed searchBioinformatics, 2005
- Developing Optimal Search Strategies for Finding Information on Herbs and Other Medicinal Plants in MEDLINE®The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, 2005
- BioIE: extracting informative sentences from the biomedical literatureBioinformatics, 2005
- XplorMed: a tool for exploring MEDLINE abstractsTrends in Biochemical Sciences, 2001
- How to perform a comprehensive search for FDG-PET literatureEuropean Journal of Nuclear Medicine and Molecular Imaging, 2000