Incorporating location uncertainty improves inference with stop-level North American Breeding Bird Survey data
- 19 May 2026
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Ornithological Applications
- Vol. 128 (3) , 1-13
Abstract
Ecological models should account for uncertainty to be most effective and useful. Yet, uncertainty from model covariates—unlike that from other sources, such as sampling error or process variability—is seldom explicitly incorporated. This can cause underestimates of uncertainty to cascade through model parameter estimates, predictions, and downstream uses. Burner et al. proposed a method for quantifying uncertainty in covariates and incorporating it into models using informative Bayesian priors. This method was applied to stop-level Breeding Bird Survey (BBS) analyses, where land cover uncertainty at each stop arises from substantial stop location uncertainty. A limited validation of model-estimated land cover, using stops with known locations, indicated the method’s potential effectiveness, but it was not rigorously evaluated. We conduct a robust simulation-based test, generating stop locations, extracting land cover, and simulating bird communities across 210 BBS routes in the upper Midwest. We compare 3 models: a “known” model with true land cover, a “naive” model assuming consistent 800-m stop spacing, and a “full” model using informative priors to estimate land cover. Species parameter estimates and predicted prevalence patterns across gradients in land cover from the full model approached those of the known model and were substantially closer to the true values used in simulations relative to those from the naive model. Naive model parameters were more biased relative to the other models, and credible intervals of predicted species prevalence rarely included the true simulated values. The full model also produced land cover covariate estimates closer to true simulation values relative to the mean informative priors. Our results show that, for the BBS, informative priors enable more accurate stop-level analyses despite location uncertainty. In contrast, naive models that ignore this uncertainty yield poor inferences. More broadly, we demonstrate empirically the utility of informative priors to account for covariate uncertainty in ecological models.Keywords
Funding Information
- U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) through the Natural Resources Preservation Program
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Using community‐reported data to understand how boat speed affects marine wildlife: An example with the Florida manateeEcological Solutions and Evidence, 2025
- Ecological scenarios: Embracing ecological uncertainty in an era of global changeEcosphere, 2025
- Thematic accuracy assessment of the NLCD 2016 land cover for the conterminous United StatesRemote Sensing of Environment, 2021
- Measurement Uncertainty in Ecological and Environmental ModelsTrends in Ecology & Evolution, 2020
- Resolving the Measurement Uncertainty Paradox in Ecological ManagementThe American Naturalist, 2019
- Outstanding Challenges in the Transferability of Ecological ModelsTrends in Ecology & Evolution, 2018
- Programming With Models: Writing Statistical Algorithms for General Model Structures With NIMBLEJournal of Computational and Graphical Statistics, 2017
- State-space models’ dirty little secrets: even simple linear Gaussian models can have estimation problemsScientific Reports, 2016
- The neglected tool in the Bayesian ecologist's shed: a case study testing informative priors' effect on model accuracyEcology and Evolution, 2014
- Habitat Selection Studies in Avian Ecology: A Critical ReviewOrnithology, 2001