The Social Production of Audit Quality in Emerging Markets: Paradoxical dependence and the pronounced tendency towards Audit Quality Minimalism

Authors:
  • MMMuntaser J. Melhem
    Muntaser J. Melhem
  • TDTamer Darwish
    Tamer Darwish
  • JHJames Haslam
    James Haslam
  • MQMuath Abdel Qader
    Muath Abdel Qader

Abstract
This study explores the social production of audit quality in branches of Big Four audit firms amid the institutional complexity of emerging markets characterised by substantively informal practices. Drawing on institutional logics, we explore how conflicting logics of professionalism, market, bureaucracy, and informal logics concentrated at the community level, notably wasta referring to informal networking in Arab societies, shape auditors’ conduct and audit quality. Using a grounded approach and a process methodological perspective, we offer a micro-level analysis of how auditors navigate these contradictions in their everyday work. Our findings reveal that informal logics undermine critical inputs into audit quality such as recruitment and performance evaluation, building a division between two groups based on informal social connections within the firm’s social structure. This engenders what we term paradoxical dependence, where one group benefits from potential independence given material resources yet loses actual independence due to informal networking, while the other group’s independence is undermined by the preferential treatment afforded to the first group. The situation leads to a tendency towards audit quality minimalism where audits are superficially performed or made to appear compliant with standards. We further show how actors alter the organizational form of branches of Big Four firms into hybrid professional social entities serving both professional and informal social roles. By highlighting how institutional complexity affects audit quality in emerging markets, this study offers insights into the interplay between macro-level logics and micro-level practices. The methods deployed expand understanding of audit quality beyond traditional archival approaches.

This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit: