‘Waterproofing layers’ for urethrocutaneous fistula repair after hypospadias surgery: evidence synthesis with systematic review and meta-analysis
Authors:
- 3 April 2023
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Pediatric Surgery International
- Vol. 39 (1) , 1-12
Abstract
Objective To summarize the available evidence and to quantitatively evaluate the global results of different waterproofing layers in substantiating the UCF repair. Material and methods After defining the study protocol, the review was conducted according to the PRISMA guidelines by a team comprising experts in hypospadiology, systematic reviews and meta-analysis, epidemiology, biostatistics and data science. Studies published from 2000 onwards, reporting on the results of UCF closure after hypospadias repair were searched for on PUBMED, Embase and Google Scholar. Study quality was assessed using Joanna Briggs Checklist (JBI) critical appraisal tool. The results with different techniques were compared with the two samples independent proportions test with the help of Microsoft Excel, MedCalc software and an online calculator. Results Seventy-three studies were shortlisted for the synthesis; the final analysis included 2886 patients (71 studies) with UCF repair failure in 539. A summary of various dimensions involved with the UCF repair has been generated including time gap after last surgery, stent-vs-no stent, supra-pubic catheterization, suture material, suturing technique, associated anomalies, complications, etc. The success rates associated with different techniques were calculated and compared: simple catheterization (100%), simple primary closure (73.2%), dartos (78.8%), double dartos flaps (81%), scrotal flaps (94.6%), tunica vaginalis (94.3%), PATIO repair (93.5%), biomaterials or dermal substitutes (92%), biocompatible adhesives (56.5%) and skin-based flaps (54.5%). Several techniques were identified as solitary publications and discussed. Conclusions Tunica vaginalis and scrotal flaps offer the best results after UCF closure in the synthesis. However, it is not possible to label any technique as ideal or perfect. Almost all popular waterproofing layers have depicted absolute (100%) success sometimes. There are a vast number of other factors (patient’s local anatomy, surgeon’s expertise and technical perspectives) which influence the final outcome.Keywords
Funding Information
- Indian Council of Medical Research, India (5/4/7-1/Uro/2020-NCD-II, 5/4/7-1/Uro/2020-NCD-II)
This publication has 68 references indexed in Scilit:
- Correction of Problematic Hypospadias with Dartos Fascia-Reinforced Flap and Slanted Incision of FistulaArchives of Plastic Surgery, 2013
- Treatment of Adults with Complications from Previous Hypospadias SurgeryJournal of Urology, 2012
- Management of urethrocutaneous fistula after hypospadias surgery - An experience of thirty-five casesIndian Journal of Plastic Surgery, 2011
- A simple procedure for management of urethrocutaneous fistulas; post-hypospadias repairAfrican Journal of Paediatric Surgery, 2010
- Use of the TIP Principle for the Repair of Non-glanular Recurrent Post Hypospadias Urethrocutaneous Mega FistulaEuropean Journal of Pediatric Surgery, 2009
- Urethrocutaneous fistula: preserve the tract and turn it inside out: the PATIO repairBJU International, 2009
- Tunneled Tunica Vaginalis Flap for Recurrent Urethrocutaneous FistulaeAdvances in Urology, 2008
- Repair of large urethrocutaneous fistula with dartos-based flip flap: A study of 23 casesIndian Journal of Plastic Surgery, 2007
- A simple novel technique [PUIT] for closure of urethrocutaneous fistula after hypospadias repair: Preliminary resultsIndian Journal of Plastic Surgery, 2005
- Use of Buccal Mucosa Patch Graft for Recurrent Large Urethrocutaneous Fistula after Hypospadias RepairUrologia Internationalis, 2004