Comment on Lu et al. Ultrathin Terahertz Dual-Band Perfect Metamaterial Absorber Using Asymmetric Double-Split Rings Resonator. Symmetry 2018, 10, 293
Open Access
Abstract
In this study, the design of a dual-band terahertz absorber, previously published by Lu et al. (Symmetry 2018, 10, 293), was re-simulated. Our findings showed significantly different absorption results from those published in the article. A detailed analysis was conducted to explain this discrepancy, which was attributed to the reflection of an unaccounted orthogonal component of the waves from the design, rather than absorption. The metasurface design has two resonances at 4.48 THz and 4.76 THz, respectively. It was reported that at these frequencies, the structure achieved absorption of 98.6% and 98.5%, respectively. However, in our results, it was found that at the second resonance (4.76 THz), the structure acted as a strong cross-polarization converter, reflecting a significant amount of incident energy in the cross-polarization component of the reflected wave. When this component is considered in the reflection coefficient calculations, the absorption reduces to 41% (from 98.5%), which is not an acceptable level for an absorber. In addition, the structure was simulated for both lossy and lossless (FR4) substrate cases to understand the effect of substrate losses. The results showed that the absorption response significantly deteriorates at the first resonance (4.48 THz) in the case of a lossy FR4 substrate.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Hybrid Dispersion Engineering based on Chiral MetamirrorLaser & Photonics Reviews, 2023
- Comment on ‘An ultrathin and broadband radar absorber using metamaterials’Waves in Random and Complex Media, 2021
- A Fully Phase‐Modulated Metasurface as An Energy‐Controllable Circular Polarization RouterAdvanced Science, 2020
- Comment on “An ultrathin and broadband metamaterial absorber using multi-layer structures” [J. Appl. Phys. 114, 064109 (2013)]Journal of Applied Physics, 2019
- Comment on “Design of a Quad-Band Wide-Angle Microwave Metamaterial Absorber”Journal of Electronic Materials, 2019
- Wide incidence angle and polarization insensitive dual broad-band metamaterial absorber based on concentric split and continuous rings resonator structureMaterials Research Express, 2018
- Design of a Quad-Band Wide-Angle Microwave Metamaterial AbsorberJournal of Electronic Materials, 2016
- A novel ultrathin and broadband microwave metamaterial absorberJournal of Applied Physics, 2014
- Ultra-broadband terahertz metamaterial absorberApplied Physics Letters, 2014
- An ultrathin and broadband metamaterial absorber using multi-layer structuresJournal of Applied Physics, 2013