Comparison of two-dimensional high-definition, ultra high-definition and three-dimensional endovision systems: an ex-vivo randomised study
- 21 September 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Surgical Endoscopy
- Vol. 35 (9) , 5328-5337
Abstract
Background Two-dimensional high-definition (2D HD) endovision system is preferred for laparoscopic surgery. Recently, new generation three-dimensional (3D) HD and ultra-HD (4K) endovision systems are introduced to improve the safety and efficacy of laparoscopic surgery. There is limited evidence on superiority of one technology over the others. This experimental trial was designed to evaluate 2D HD, 3D HD and 4K HD endovision systems in performance of standardized tasks. Methods This was a randomized, cross-over experimental study. Twenty-one surgical residents who were exposed to laparoscopic surgery were enrolled. Participants were randomly assigned into three groups. Each group performed standardised tasks i.e. peg transfer, precision cutting, navigating in space and intra-corporeal suturing using 2D HD, 4K HD and 3D HD endovision systems on a box trainer. Procedures were recorded as 2D HD videos and analysed later. Participant’s perceived workload was assessed using Surg-TLX questionnaire. Primary endpoints were execution time in seconds and error score. Secondary endpoint was workload assessment. Results The 3D HD had shorter execution time compared to 2D HD and 4K HD in all tasks except precision cutting (p = 0.004, 0.03, 0.001, 0.001 and p = 0.002, 0.191, 0.006, 0.005 in peg transfer, precision cutting, navigating in space and intra-corporeal suturing respectively). The 4K HD was significantly faster than 2D HD only in navigating in space task (p = 0.002). The error score between 3D HD and 4K HD were comparable in all tasks. The 2D HD had significantly more error scores compared to 4K HD, 3D HD in peg transfer task (p = 0.005, 0.014, respectively). 3D HD had significantly less workload than 2D HD and 4K HD in most of the dimensions of Surg-TLX Conclusions 3D HD endovision system in comparison to 2D HD and 4K HD, may lead to faster execution without compromising safety of a task and is associated with less workload.Keywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Computer-assisted 3D bowel length measurement for quantitative laparoscopySurgical Endoscopy, 2018
- Skills Comparison in Pediatric Residents Using a 2-Dimensional versus a 3-Dimensional High-Definition Camera in a Pediatric Laparoscopic SimulatorJournal of Surgical Education, 2017
- Impact of simulated three-dimensional perception on precision of depth judgements, technical performance and perceived workload in laparoscopyBritish Journal of Surgery, 2017
- Stereoscopic (3D) versus monoscopic (2D) laparoscopy: comparative study of performance using advanced HD optical systems in a surgical simulator modelWorld Journal of Urology, 2015
- An assessment of the new generation three-dimensional high definition laparoscopic vision system on surgical skills: a randomized prospective studySurgical Endoscopy, 2014
- Three-dimensional imaging improves surgical skill performance in a laparoscopic test model for both experienced and novice laparoscopic surgeonsSurgical Endoscopy, 2014
- 2D Versus 3D Visualization: Impact on Laparoscopic Proficiency Using the Fundamentals of Laparoscopic Surgery Skill SetJournal of Laparoendoscopic & Advanced Surgical Techniques, 2012
- 3D HD versus 2D HD: surgical task efficiency in standardised phantom tasksSurgical Endoscopy, 2011
- High Definition Laparoscopy: Objective Assessment of Performance Characteristics and Comparison with Standard LaparoscopyJournal of Endourology, 2009
- Visual fatigue caused by viewing stereoscopic motion images: Background, theories, and observationsDisplays, 2008