Uniqueness in the life sciences: how did the elephant get its trunk?
Authors:
Open Access
- 19 July 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Biology & Philosophy
- Vol. 36 (4) , 1-24
Abstract
Researchers in the life sciences often make uniqueness attributions; about branching events generating new species, the developmental processes generating novel traits and the distinctive cultural selection pressures faced by hominins. Yet since uniqueness implies non-recurrence, such attributions come freighted with epistemic consequences. Drawing on the work of Aviezer Tucker, we show that a common reaction to uniqueness attributions is pessimism: both about the strength of candidate explanations as well as the ability to even generate such explanations. Looking at two case studies—elephant trunks and human teaching—we develop a more optimistic account. As we argue, uniqueness attributions are revisable claims about the availability of several different kinds of comparators. Yet even as researchers investigate the availability of such comparators, they are able to mobilize complex sets of empirical and theoretical tools. Rather than hindering scientific investigation, then, we argue that uniqueness attributions often spur the generation of a range of epistemic goods.Keywords
Funding Information
- Leverhulme Trust (ECF-2018-005)
- Isaac Newton Trust (G101655)
This publication has 55 references indexed in Scilit:
- What Evolvability Really IsThe British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 2014
- Historicity and experimental evolutionBiology & Philosophy, 2011
- Why Humans Are Unique: Three TheoriesPerspectives on Psychological Science, 2010
- What, if Anything, Is an Evolutionary Novelty?Philosophy of Science, 2008
- Variation in contributions to teaching by meerkatsProceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences, 2008
- The Chimpanzee Has No ClothesCurrent Anthropology, 2008
- Is convergence more than an analogy? Homoplasy and its implications for macroevolutionary predictabilityBiology & Philosophy, 2007
- A new small-bodied hominin from the Late Pleistocene of Flores, IndonesiaNature, 2004
- Historical Evidence and Human AdaptationsPhilosophy of Science, 2002
- The Function of General Laws in HistoryThe Journal of Philosophy, 1942