Should desperate volunteers be included in randomised controlled trials?
Authors:
- P AllmarkPAP Allmark
- S MasonSMS Mason
- 30 August 2006
- journal article
- review article
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 32 (9) , 548-553
Abstract
Randomised controlled trials (RCTs) sometimes recruit participants who are desperate to receive the experimental treatment. This paper defends the practice against three arguments that suggest it is unethical first, desperate volunteers are not in equipoise. Second clinicians, entering patients onto trials are disavowing their therapeutic obligation to deliver the best treatment; they are following trial protocols rather than delivering individualised care. Research is not treatment; its ethical justification is different. Consent is crucial. Third, desperate volunteers do not give proper consent: effectively, they are coerced. This paper responds by advocating a notion of equipoise based on expert knowledge and widely shared values. Where such collective, expert equipoise exists there is a prima facie case for an RCT. Next the paper argues that trial entry does not involve clinicians disavowing their therapeutic obligation; individualised care based on insufficient evidence is not in patients best interest. Finally, it argues that where equipoise exists it is acceptable to limit access to experimental agents; desperate volunteers are not coerced because their desperation does not translate into a right to receive what they desire.Keywords
This publication has 46 references indexed in Scilit:
- Issues to debate on the Women's Health Initiative (WHI) study. Epidemiology or randomized clinical trials--time out for hormone replacement therapy studies?Human Reproduction, 2003
- Clinical Equipoise and the Therapeutic MisconceptionHastings Center Report, 2003
- Therapeutic obligation in clinical research.2003
- Rehabilitating EquipoiseKennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 2003
- Ethical issues in human prion diseasesBritish Medical Bulletin, 2003
- Ethics of clinical trials from a bayesian and decision analytic perspective: whose equipoise is it anyway?BMJ, 2003
- A Critique of Clinical Equipoise: Therapeutic Misconception in the Ethics of Clinical TrialsHastings Center Report, 2003
- The Therapeutic Orientation to Clinical TrialsNew England Journal of Medicine, 2003
- Update on unethical use of placebos in randomised trialsBioethics, 2003
- THE UBIQUITY AND UTILITY OF THE THERAPEUTIC MISCONCEPTIONSocial Philosophy and Policy, 2002