The Effect of Competition on the Efficient–Responsive Choice
- 15 June 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Production and Operations Management
- Vol. 23 (5) , 829-846
Abstract
In determining their operations strategy, a firm chooses whether to be responsive or efficient. For firms competing in a market with uncertain demand and varying intensity of substitutability for the competitor's product, we characterize the responsive or efficient choice in equilibrium. To focus first on the competitive implications, we study a model where a firm can choose to be responsive at no additional fixed or marginal cost. We find that competing firms will choose the same configuration (responsive or efficient), and responsiveness tends to be favorable when demand uncertainty is high or when product competition is not too strong. Intense competition can drive firms to choose to be efficient rather than responsive even when there is no additional cost of being responsive. In such a case, both firms would be better off by choosing to be responsive but cannot credibly commit. We extend the basic model to study the impact of endogenized production timing, multiple productions and product holdback (or, equivalently, postponed production). For all these settings, we find structurally similar results; firms choose the same configuration, and the firms may miss Pareto‐improvements. Furthermore, through extensions to the basic model, we find that greater operational flexibility can make responsiveness look less attractive in the presence of product competition. In contrast to our basic model and other extensions, we find it is possible for one firm to be responsive while the other is efficient when there is either a fixed cost or variable cost premium associated with responsive delivery.Keywords
Funding Information
- National University of Singapore Academic Research (R‐314‐000‐076‐133, R‐314‐000‐084‐112)
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Quick Response and Retailer EffortManagement Science, 2010
- Competing Manufacturers in a Retail Supply Chain: On Contractual Form and CoordinationManagement Science, 2010
- Optimal Market Intelligence Strategy When Management Attention Is ScarceManagement Science, 2009
- The Strategic Perils of Delayed DifferentiationManagement Science, 2007
- Strategic Technology Choice and Capacity Investment Under Demand UncertaintyManagement Science, 2007
- Aligning Supply Chain Strategies with Product UncertaintiesCalifornia Management Review, 2002
- CONFIGURING A SUPPLY CHAIN TO REDUCE THE COST OF DEMAND UNCERTAINTYProduction and Operations Management, 1997
- Quick Response in Manufacturer-Retailer ChannelsManagement Science, 1997
- Reducing the Cost of Demand Uncertainty Through Accurate Response to Early SalesOperations Research, 1996
- Manufacturing Flexibility: A Strategic PerspectiveManagement Science, 1993