The Effects of Jointly Provided Tax Services and Auditor Size on Restatements
Authors:
- Matthew A. NotbohmMNMatthew A. Notbohm
- Jeffrey S. PatersonJPJeffrey S. Paterson
- Adrian ValenciaAVAdrian Valencia
- 26 October 2015
- book chapter
- Published by Emerald Publishing
- p. 109-143
Abstract
Prior research finds evidence that audit quality is positively associated with the joint purchase of tax nonaudit services (NAS) and concludes that jointly provided tax services result in audit-related knowledge spillovers that lead to improved audit quality. We extend this line of research. We examine the relation between auditor-provided tax services and restatements and determine whether this relation differs when the auditor is a small or large accounting firm. We also examine whether the Securities Exchange Commission’s restrictions on certain tax consulting practices (SEC, 2006) altered this relation. Specifically, we measure whether the probability of financial statement restatements varies with (1) variation in accounting firm size (measured as PCAOB annually inspected firms versus PCAOB triennially inspected firms), and (2) the joint provision of audit and tax services. We find a negative relation between auditor-provided tax services and restatements which is consistent with prior research. We also find that this relation is significantly more negative when the auditor is a small accounting firm. Finally, we find that the lower probability of a restatement associated with the joint provision of audit and tax services persists regardless of auditor size after the SEC-imposed restrictions on certain tax consulting services in 2006. Our study provides evidence that accounting firms, and particularly small accounting firms, benefit from knowledge spillovers when jointly providing audit and tax services and these benefits lead to improved audit quality. Prior research concludes that large auditors provide higher audit quality and that the provision of tax services improves audit quality. Our results provide evidence that audit quality improvements are greater for small auditors and their clients. This improvement narrows that audit quality gap between large and small auditors. We do not find evidence that the SEC’s restrictions on certain tax consulting services altered the relation between audit quality and tax services.Keywords
This publication has 64 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Emergence of Second‐Tier Auditors in the US: Evidence from Investor Perceptions of Financial Reporting CredibilityJournal of Business Finance & Accounting, 2013
- Effects of Audit Quality on Earnings Management and Cost of Equity Capital: Evidence from China*Contemporary Accounting Research, 2011
- Do the Big 4 and the Second-tier firms provide audits of similar quality?Journal of Accounting and Public Policy, 2010
- How does internal control regulation affect financial reporting?Journal of Accounting and Economics, 2010
- The Effect of SOX Internal Control Deficiencies on Firm Risk and Cost of EquityJournal of Accounting Research, 2009
- Earnings Management Strategies and the Trade-Off between Tax Benefits and Detection Risk: To Conform or Not to Conform?The Accounting Review, 2009
- An Analysis of Cross-Sectional Differences in Big and Non-Big Public Accounting Firms' Audit ProgramsAUDITING: A Journal of Practice & Theory, 2006
- Do Nonaudit Services Compromise Auditor Independence? Further EvidenceThe Accounting Review, 2003
- The Effect of Audit Quality on Earnings Management*Contemporary Accounting Research, 1998
- The jointness of audit fees and demand for MAS: A self‐selection analysis*Contemporary Accounting Research, 1990