The Impact of Formal One-to-One Mentoring Upon Vulnerable Young People: A Systematic Review
Open Access
- 24 July 2026
- journal article
- review article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Youth & Society
Abstract
This systematic review synthesizes evidence from 24 empirical studies to examine the impact of formal one-to-one mentoring on the wellbeing and development of vulnerable young people. Guided by an ecological framework informed by Bronfenbrenner’s Ecological Systems Theory, the review identifies three interrelated themes: relational processes within the mentoring dyad, program structures that support relationship stability, and outcomes across psychosocial, educational, and social domains. Findings indicate that trust, compatibility, and sustained engagement are central to effective mentoring, but these relational processes rely on strong organizational supports, including training, supervision, and planned closure. Cultural humility, contextual responsiveness, and sensitivity to structural inequities further influence engagement and impact. Across studies, mentoring effects were generally modest, but more evident when relational and program structures were well aligned. Drawing on these findings, the review proposes the Ecological Framework for Youth Mentoring, comprising five principles for stable, contextually grounded, and effective mentoring with vulnerable young people. Overall, the review positions mentoring within a broader ecology of care rather than as a stand-alone intervention, with implications for program design, equity, and future research.Keywords
Funding Information
- Australian Government Research Training Program
This publication has 60 references indexed in Scilit:
- Pathways by which case managers' match support influences youth mentoring outcomes: Testing the systemic model of youth mentoringJournal of Community Psychology, 2023
- A randomized controlled trial of enhanced mentoring program practices for children of incarcerated caregivers: Assessing impacts on youth and match outcomesJournal of Community Psychology, 2023
- Paraprofessional Youth Mentoring: A Framework for Integrating Youth Mentoring with Helping Institutions and ProfessionsAmerican Journal of Community Psychology, 2021
- Mentors' experiences of mentoring justice‐involved adolescents: A narrative of developing cultural consciousness through connectionJournal of Community Psychology, 2020
- “It's like all of his attention is on you”: A mixed methods examination of attachment, supportive nonparental youth–adult relationships, and self‐esteem during adolescenceJournal of Community Psychology, 2018
- Mentoring Relationship Quality and Maltreated Children's CopingAmerican Journal of Community Psychology, 2017
- MENTORING RELATIONSHIPS, POSITIVE DEVELOPMENT, YOUTH EMOTIONAL AND BEHAVIORAL PROBLEMS: INVESTIGATION OF A MEDIATIONAL MODELJournal of Community Psychology, 2016
- The Functions and Longitudinal Outcomes of Adolescents’ Naturally Occurring MentorshipsAmerican Journal of Community Psychology, 2016
- Mentoring Relationship Closures in Big Brothers Big Sisters Community Mentoring Programs: Patterns and Associated Risk FactorsAmerican Journal of Community Psychology, 2016
- A model for the influence of mentoring relationships on youth developmentJournal of Community Psychology, 2006