How do children's nurses make clinical decisions? Two preliminary studies
Authors:
- Alison TwycrossATAlison Twycross
- Lucy PowlsLPLucy Powls
- 12 September 2006
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Clinical Nursing
- Vol. 15 (10) , 1324-1335
Abstract
Aims and objectives. To gain an understanding of how children's nurses make clinical decisions.Background. Several studies have explored how nurses make clinical decisions and the factors that may affect the decision‐making strategies used. However, the results of these studies are contradictory. Further, little is known about children's nurses’ decision‐making strategies.Design. The think aloud technique.Methods. Nurses (n = 12) from three surgical wards and nurses (n = 15) from three medical wards in a Scottish children's hospital were presented with clinical scenarios and asked to think aloud. The verbal protocols were analysed to provide an indication of how children's nurses made decisions. Whether there were any differences in decision‐making between experienced and less experienced nurses and between graduates and non‐graduates was also explored.Results. Analysis of verbal protocols obtained using the think aloud technique suggested that all the nurses in the sample used a hypothetico‐deductive (analytical) model of decision‐making. Further, all participants appeared to use backward reasoning strategies regardless of their level of expertise. This is a characteristic of non‐expert decision‐making. Experienced and less experienced nurses collected similar additional information before planning nursing interventions, supporting the conjecture that they were functioning at a non‐expert level in relation to decision‐making. No differences were seen in the information collected by graduate and non‐graduate nurses.Conclusions. The decision‐making strategies of children's nurses need exploring further and further research is needed to identify factors that may affect decision‐making strategies. Several strategies to support nurses’ clinical decision‐making have been proposed but need testing to ascertain their effectiveness.Relevance to clinical practice. In clinical practice nurses make numerous decisions throughout the course of a shift. Sub‐optimal decision‐making strategies may adversely affect the quality of nursing care provided. It is imperative, therefore, to ascertain how nurses make clinical decisions and the factors that may influence the decision‐making strategies used.Keywords
This publication has 60 references indexed in Scilit:
- Processes used bynurses to make decisions in the clinical practice settingNurse Education Today, 1997
- Beyond expertise: theory, practice and the reflexive practitionerJournal of Clinical Nursing, 1997
- Judgements and processes in care decisions in acute medical and surgical wardsJournal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 1996
- Domain-Specific Knowledge and Task Characteristics in Decision MakingOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 1995
- Some surprising similarities in the clinical reasoning of‘expert’ and ‘novice’ orthopaedic nurses: report of a study using verbal protocols and protocol analysesJournal of Advanced Nursing, 1995
- Content and Process in Clinical Decision‐Making by Nurse PractitionersImage: the Journal of Nursing Scholarship, 1992
- Intuition in Decision‐makingImage: the Journal of Nursing Scholarship, 1988
- Knowledge based solution strategies in medical reasoningCognitive Science, 1986
- FROM NOVICE TO EXPERTAJN, American Journal of Nursing, 1984
- Nursing decision making in critical care areasJournal of Advanced Nursing, 1982