Confusing and contradictory: considering obesity discourse and eating disorders as they shape body pedagogies in HPE
Authors:
- 4 May 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Sport, Education and Society
- Vol. 15 (2) , 221-233
Abstract
We suggest that recent concerns about young people's excess body weight have generally been treated quite separately to longer standing concerns about young people (particularly, young women) and eating disorders. The few papers that have addressed this connection directly have focused on how practices motivated by the obesity discourse have had damaging consequences for the ways young women have come to understand and act on their bodies. The research described in this paper, however, makes a different point. It demonstrates how one teacher struggles to negotiate the different and often contradictory meanings about the body and young women's health, in a context where explicit teaching about eating disorders and body image is formally endorsed and legislated through the State health and physical education (HPE) syllabus. The interview material and classroom exchanges described in the paper are from a project that examined the implementation of a sociocultural perspective as a curriculum change in HPE. The case presented here took place in a girls' private school, where an accomplished female HPE head teacher developed and taught a unit of work focused on food and nutrition to a class of 15- and 16-year-old female students. Our analysis suggests that, within this particular gendered and classed setting, the teacher understood the students in her class as being at greater risk of developing eating disorders than of becoming obese. However, despite the apparent ‘risk’ presented by eating disorders, the investments both students and the teacher had in their own bodies as the slim ideal, meant that learning and teaching about how to avoid being fat continued to be paramount. We suggest further research is required to understand how teachers negotiate the intersection of obesity and eating disorders in the formal curriculum and across different social and cultural contexts, and to draw on this in advising teachers in relation to future practice.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- The paradox of virtue: (re)thinking deviance, anorexia and schoolingGender and Education, 2007
- Implicit anti-fat bias in physical educators: physical attributes, ideology and socializationInternational Journal of Obesity, 2006
- The Last Word: Stop the War on Weight: Obesity and Eating Disorder Prevention Working Together Toward HealthEating Disorders, 2006
- Can we simultaneously work toward the prevention of obesity and eating disorders in children and adolescents?International Journal of Eating Disorders, 2005
- The Role of Teachers and Other Educators in the Prevention of Eating Disorders and Child Obesity: What Are the Issues?Eating Disorders, 2005
- Rethinking the preparation of HPE teachers: ruminations on knowledge, identity, and ways of thinkingAsia-Pacific Journal of Teacher Education, 2004
- ‘Healthy Weight’ at What Cost? ‘Bulimia’ and a Discourse of Weight ControlJournal of Health Psychology, 2004
- New moves: a school-based obesity prevention program for adolescent girlsPreventive Medicine, 2003
- ‘The only Problem is, children will like their chips’: education and the discursive production of ill-healthPedagogy, Culture & Society, 2003
- Fat free schooling: The discursive production of ill-healthInternational Studies in Sociology of Education, 2002