A transport‐distance approach to scaling erosion rates: 3. Evaluating scaling characteristics of Mahleran
- 23 January 2008
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Earth Surface Processes and Landforms
- Vol. 33 (7) , 1113-1128
Abstract
In the two previous papers of this series, we demonstrated how a novel approach to erosion modelling (Mahleran – Model for Assessing Hillslope‐Landscape Erosion, Runoff And Nutrients) provided distinct advantages in terms of process representation and explicit scaling characteristics when compared with existing models. A first evaluation furthermore demonstrated the ability of the model to reproduce spatial and temporal patterns of erosion and their particle‐size characteristics on a large rainfall‐simulation plot. In this paper, we carry out a more detailed evaluation of the model using monitored erosion events on plots of different size. The evaluation uses four plots of 21·01, 115·94, 56·84 and 302·19 m2, with lengths of 4·12, 14·48, 18·95 and 27·78 m, respectively, on similar soils to the rainfall‐simulation plot, for which runoff and erosion were monitored under natural rainfall. Although the model produces the correct ranking of the magnitude of erosion events, it performs less well in reproducing the absolute values and particle‐size distributions of the eroded sediment. The implications of these results are evaluated in terms of requirements for process understanding and data for parameterization of improved soil‐erosion models. We suggest that there are major weaknesses in the current understanding and data underpinning existing models. Consequently, a more holistic re‐evaluation is required that produces functional relationships for different processes that are mutually consistent, and that have appropriate parameterization data to support their use in a wide range of environmental conditions. Copyright © 2008 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.Keywords
This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- On undermining the science?Hydrological Processes, 2006
- Exponential Distribution Theory and the Interpretation of Splash Detachment and Transport ExperimentsSoil Science Society of America Journal, 2002
- A Process-Based Evaluation of a Process-Based Soil-Erosion Model2000
- Sensitivity of Sediment-Transport Equations to Errors in Hydraulic Models of Overland Flow1998
- Numerical Algorithms with Fortran1996
- Detachment of Soil by Flowing Water Under Turbulent and Laminar ConditionsSoil Science Society of America Journal, 1994
- Sediment Concentrations Resulting from Flow Depth/Drop Size Interactions in Shallow Overland FlowTransactions of the ASAE, 1993
- A Probabilistic Model Of Soil Detachment By Shallow Turbulent FlowTransactions of the ASAE, 1991
- Distribution of depth of overland flow on desert hillslopes and its implications for modeling soil erosionJournal of Hydrology, 1989
- Concepts of mathematical modeling of sediment yieldWater Resources Research, 1974