Ensuring Knowledge Transfer: The Critical Role of “What-If” Discussions in Virtual Patient Simulation
Open Access
- 20 January 2026
- journal article
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in Perspectives on Medical Education
- Vol. 15 (1) , 633-643
Abstract
Background: Virtual Patient (VP) systems are widely used in medical education, yet evidence on how they support near and far transfer remains limited. This study investigates integrating VPs with role modelling, varied case practices, and “what-if” discussions. It aims to measure the students’ overall experience with the intervention, improvement in performance scores on near- and far-transfer cases, and to explore how and why the intervention is perceived to enhance transfer. Methods: An exploratory mixed-methods study was conducted with 21 second-year undergraduate medical students enrolled in the course “Personalised Medicine in Cancer Treatment and Care”. Students engaged in role modelling performed by an oncologist, worked through authentic cases with varying patient characteristics, and participated in structured “what-if” discussions. Perceptions about the overall experience were gathered through a 19-item survey (n = 21). Performance scores were evaluated using pre- and post-assessments involving VPs and paper-based cases designed to measure near transfer (Case D) and far transfer (Case E) (n = 21). Group interviews (n = 8) provided deeper insights into enhancing transfer. Results: Survey results revealed positive student perceptions of role modelling (M = 4.44), varied case practices (M = 4.35), and “what-if” discussions (M = 3.76). Significant improvements were observed in tumour-stage reasoning for both near and far transfer (p < .001), in initial patient impressions (p = .007) for far transfer, and in the total score (p = .018) for far transfer. Thematic analysis indicated that students benefited from a stepwise build-up in case complexity, recognition of similar reasoning steps across cases, reflective “what-if” discussions that highlighted underlying principles, and peer dialogue around VP feedback that supported concept abstraction. Conclusions: Students evaluated the VP session positively and performance data indicated significant improvements, suggesting that the intervention enhanced near and far transfer. Reflection through “what-if” discussions was perceived to deepen understanding of the underlying principles enabling transfer.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- A meta-analysis of the experimental evidence on the near- and far-transfer effects among children’s executive function skills.Psychological Bulletin, 2019
- A Guideline of Selecting and Reporting Intraclass Correlation Coefficients for Reliability ResearchJournal of Chiropractic Medicine, 2016
- Virtual patients as activities: exploring the research implications of an activity theoretical stancePerspectives on Medical Education, 2014
- Is working memory training effective? A meta-analytic review.Developmental Psychology, 2013
- Mechanisms of knowledge transferThinking & Reasoning, 2009
- “What if…”: The Use of Conceptual Simulations in Scientific ReasoningCognitive Science, 2007
- A conceptual framework for developing teaching cases: a review and synthesis of the literature across disciplinesMedical Education, 2006
- What every teacher needs to know about clinical reasoningMedical Education, 2004
- Random comparison of ‘virtual patient’ models in the context of teaching clinical communication skillsMedical Education, 2001
- Exploring the Etiology of Content SpecificityAcademic Medicine, 1998