The Ethics of Observing
- 1 July 2008
- journal article
- review article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Teaching Sociology
- Vol. 36 (3) , 196-210
Abstract
In this article I explore the ethical terrain of experiential learning activities drawing on my experiences leading college students on field trips into criminal justice settings. Though there are numerous educational benefits to adopting experiential learning activities, the rewards must be evaluated in light of the potential harms to nonstudent participants. Student observations of criminal justice settings can reinforce common stereotypes of prisoners as scary and dangerous while reifying the legitimacy of state power exercised through agents of social control. More broadly, experiential learning activities can also highlight the shame and embarrassment of subordinate groups when such activities devolve into voyeuristic spectacles of human misery. In light of these potential harms to nonstudent groups, this article proposes guiding questions for educators to address in designing experiential activities. These questions draw attention to the following issues: the vulnerability of participants, the relative social power of nonstudent participants, whether participation is truly voluntary, the accessibility of the setting to outside observers, group size, benefits to nonstudent participants, duration of activity, protection of confidentiality, the role of students in the activity, and the curricular focus of the experience.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Hop on the Bus: Driving Stratification Concepts HomeTeaching Sociology, 2004
- A Troubling Success Story: Revisiting a Classic Deviance Assignment in a Criminology CourseTeaching Sociology, 2001
- Field Trips as Short-Term Experiential EducationTeaching Sociology, 1997
- Reducing Ethnocentrism: A Cross-Cultural Experience for Sociology ClassesTeaching Sociology, 1994
- Experiential Service-Based Learning: An Integrated HIV/AIDS Education Model for College CampusesTeaching Sociology, 1993
- Alcoholics Anonymous Meetings for Teaching SociologyTeaching Sociology, 1992
- Urban Political Economy and Experiential Learning: Designing the Course "Sociology of Dubuque"Teaching Sociology, 1989
- Incorporating Women and Crime Topics into Criminology Classes: Assignments Exercises, and ProjectsTeaching Sociology, 1987
- Teaching Family Sociology through Case StudiesTeaching Sociology, 1984
- Conditions of Successful Degradation CeremoniesAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1956