Compare the pair: Rotated versus unrotated surface codes at equal logical error rates
Open Access
- 18 July 2025
- journal article
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Research
- Vol. 7 (3)
Abstract
Practical quantum computers will require resource-efficient error-correcting codes. The rotated surface code uses approximately half the number of qubits as the unrotated surface code to create a logical qubit with the same error-correcting distance. However, instead of distance, a more useful qubit-saving metric would be based on logical error rates. In this work we find the well-below-threshold scaling of logical to physical error rates under circuit-level noise for both codes at high odd and even distances and then compare the number of qubits used by each code to achieve equal logical error rates. We perform Monte Carlo sampling of memory experiment circuits with all valid CNOT orders using the stabilizer simulator Stim and the uncorrelated minimum-weight perfect matching decoder PyMatching 2. We find that the rotated code uses about 74 % the number of qubits used by the unrotated code to achieve a logical error rate of p L = 10 − 12 at the operational physical error rate of p = 10 − 3 . The ratio remains ≈ 75 % for p values within a factor of two of p = 10 − 3 for all useful p L . Our work finds the low- p L scaling of the surface code and clarifies the qubit savings provided by the rotated surface code, providing numerical justification for its use in future implementations of the surface code.Keywords
All Related Versions
Funding Information
- Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (HR00112230007, HR001121S0026)
- University of Technology Sydney
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- Quantum error correction below the surface code thresholdNature, 2024
- Single-step parity check gate set for quantum error correctionQuantum Science and Technology, 2024
- Parallel window decoding enables scalable fault tolerant quantum computationNature Communications, 2023
- Suppressing quantum errors by scaling a surface code logical qubitNature, 2023
- The role of entropy in topological quantum error correctionJournal of Statistical Mechanics: Theory and Experiment, 2019
- High-speed quantum networking by shipScientific Reports, 2016
- Quantum error correction for beginnersReports on Progress in Physics, 2013
- Surface code quantum computing by lattice surgeryNew Journal of Physics, 2012
- Fault-tolerant quantum computation by anyonsAnnals of Physics, 2003
- Topological quantum memoryJournal of Mathematical Physics, 2002