The ethics of basing community prevention in general practice
Authors:
- Michael WeingartenMWMichael Weingarten
- Andre MatalonAMAndre Matalon
- 8 March 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 36 (3) , 138-141
Abstract
In this paper we argue that the responsibility for systematic community-based preventive medicine should not be made part of the role of the general practitioner (GP). Preventive medicine cannot be shown to be more effective than curative or supportive medicine. Therefore, the allocation of the large amount of general practice staff time and resources required for systematic preventive medicine should not come at the expense of the care of the sick and the suffering. The traditional healing role of the GP requires a cooperative patient-centred approach, whereas systematic preventive medicine is driven by rigid pre-set protocols and is intrinsically paternalistic. Trying to merge the two approaches is detrimental to the doctor-patient relationship. Furthermore, a number of potential pitfalls are identified that may be encountered in the implementation of preventive medicine programmes in general practice: interference with the course of the consultation; inadequate explanation and consent; distortion of practice priorities as reflected in quality indicators; temptation to record inaccurate data; conflict of interests where the doctor is rewarded for performance; patient blaming; exacerbation of the health gap. We suggest that a more justifiable strategy would be for GPs to identify patients at high risk and offer them specific preventive advice when the opportunity presents itself and at a time when the patient is likely to be most amenable to cooperate. Opportunistic health promotion offers higher expectations of benefit, as well as a more equitable allocation of the risks associated with preventive medicine, than a systematic community-based approach.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- 6 EZ Steps to Improving Your PerformanceJAMA, 2008
- Physician advice for smoking cessation2008
- Screening for colorectal cancer using the faecal occult blood test, HemoccultCochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2007
- Screening for breast cancer with mammography2006
- Screening for prostate cancer2006
- Prevention and health promotion in clinical practice: the views of general practitioners in EuropePreventive Medicine, 2005
- Ethical dilemmas arising from implementation of the European guidelines on cardiovascular disease prevention in clinical practiceA descriptive epidemiological studyScandinavian Journal of Primary Health Care, 2004
- When the population approach to prevention puts the health of individuals at riskInternational Journal of Epidemiology, 2004
- The inverse care law todayThe Lancet, 2002
- Psychology and screening: Narrowing the gap between efficacy and effectiveness*British Journal of Clinical Psychology, 1994