How Relevant is NIMBYism to Citizens’ Support for the Large-Scale Deployment of Public Goods? Experimental Evidence from 5G Antenna Placement in Switzerland
Open Access
- 29 May 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Political Behavior
- Vol. 48 (2) , 721-749
Abstract
Supplying society-wide public goods often depends on site-specific provision. Yet, (perceived) localized provision costs may at times outweigh localized individual benefits and thus lead to “not-in-my-backyard” (NIMBY-)opposition (e.g., when trying to set up energy, transportation, social, or, in our case, communication infrastructure). Accurate estimation of the level of NIMBY-opposition per se is analytically challenging because general attitudes towards provision and NIMBY-motivated opposition are intertwined but need to be distinguished and because site selection can be endogenous to local support/opposition. We conducted an experiment that addresses these challenges, focusing on public attitudes toward 5G antenna placement in Switzerland. Using original data from a population-representative sample of Swiss residents ( $$N=5,035$$ ), we observe a population split on the question of 5G network expansion. We survey-experimentally revealed actual 5G antenna locations around respondent homes to a sample largely unaware of these locations beforehand. This information increased individuals’ worry over proximity to antenna sites and reduced support for 5G rollout, with such effects becoming stronger with closer proximity. Differentiating respondents with ex ante higher perceived costs/lower perceived benefits and lower costs/higher benefits from provision, the former are more opposed to 5G rollout, regardless of distance. In contrast, the latter exhibit particularly pronounced NIMBY attitudes. This allows for unexpected political coalitions that, in our case, could affect majority support. In additional experiments, we show that NIMBY attitudes translate into a higher willingness to pay for opposition in close proximity to new provision sites—but this could potentially be mitigated by scenarios where citizens decide under a veil of ignorance.
Keywords
Funding Information
- Universität Konstanz
This publication has 44 references indexed in Scilit:
- Construing hypotheticals: How hypotheticality affects level of abstractionJournal of Experimental Social Psychology, 2023
- Factual information on the environmental impacts of consumption abroad increases citizens' problem awareness, but not support for mitigating such impactsEnvironmental Science & Policy, 2023
- Accepting and resisting densification: The importance of project-related factors and the contextualizing role of neighbourhoodsLandscape and Urban Planning, 2022
- Effects of spatial proximity to proposed electric power lines on residents' expectations, attitudes, and protest behavior: A replication studyEnergy Policy, 2019
- Exploring landowners’ post-construction changes in perceptions of wind energy in MichiganLand Use Policy, 2019
- In Whose Backyard? The Wicked Problem of Siting Nuclear Waste RepositoriesEuropean Policy Analysis, 2017
- A mast is a mast is a mast…? Comparison of preferences for location-scenarios of electricity pylons and wind power plants using conjoint analysisEnergy Policy, 2017
- Beyond NIMBYism: towards an integrated framework for understanding public perceptions of wind energyWind Energy, 2004
- Wind power and the NIMBY-myth: institutional capacity and the limited significance of public supportRenewable Energy, 2000
- NIMBY taxes matter: the case of state hazardous waste disposal taxesJournal of Public Economics, 1999