Beyond Legalism: Towards a Thicker Understanding of Transitional Justice
Author:
Top Cited Papers
- 20 November 2007
- journal article
- conference paper
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Law and Society
- Vol. 34 (4) , 411-440
Abstract
The field of transitional justice is increasingly characterized by the dominance of legalism to the detriment of both scholarship and practice. The first part of the paper examines what is meant by legalism and its consequences in the field through a number of overlapping themes: ‘legalism as seduction’, the ‘triumph’ of human rights, and the tendency towards ‘seeing like a state’. The second part considers a number of correctives to such leanings which are analysed as encouraging legal humility, exploring the human rights as development axis, and finally developing a criminology of transitional justice. As law's place at the heart of transition from conflict is now secure, the time is right for a more honest appraisal of the limitations of legalism and a correspondingly greater willingness to countenance the role of other [non‐legal] actors and forms of knowledge. ‘Letting go of legalism’ will both thicken the subject and deliver more effective change on the ground.Keywords
This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- Criminalizing War: Criminology as CeasefireSocial & Legal Studies, 2005
- State Crime by Proxy and Juridical OtheringThe British Journal of Criminology, 2005
- Rebuilding governance in failed states and post‐conflict societies: core concepts and cross‐cutting themesPublic Administration and Development, 2005
- The Paradox of Transition in Conflicted DemocraciesHuman Rights Quarterly, 2005
- Beyond the Metaphor:Theoretical Criminology, 2003
- For Criminology in International Criminal JusticeJournal of International Criminal Justice, 2003
- Thickening Thin Concepts and Theories: Combining Large N and Small in Comparative PoliticsComparative Politics, 1999
- Prisoner Release and Conflict Resolution: International Lessons for Northern IrelandInternational Criminal Justice Review, 1998
- The Rule of Law RevivalForeign Affairs, 1998
- Fin de Siècle CriminologyTheoretical Criminology, 1997