The growth of the far right in the United States has been fueled by overlapping trends including the consolidation and growth of militia groups, the popularity of conspiracy theories like Q’Anon and Pizzagate, and the availability of social media platforms for recruitment, networking, and production of shared repertoire of memes and ideas. It also has been influenced by attempts to build a U.S. version of identitarianism that would make xenophobia, doctrines of white superiority, and traditional patriarchy attractive to a wider range of potential adherents. The rise of the “alt-right” in the 2010s was linked to the formation of several identitarian organizations, the most prominent of which was Identity Evropa (IE; later renamed the American Identity Movement). Yet this group existed for less than five years, dissolving unceremoniously in late 2020. This chapter explores why European-style identitarianism floundered on organizational terms in the United States, even as white identity politics gained significant traction. I examine the founding, ideologies, and activities of IE, and argue that the particularities of the far-right landscape in the United States complicated and stymied identitarianism as a bonafide movement. Despite its organizational limits, the dissemination of identitarian ideas worked to enlarge the conditions of possibility for the radicalization of white Americans who express anxieties about the country’s changing racial demographics.