Deception in Sports
Author:
Open Access
- 16 April 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of the Philosophy of Sport
- Vol. 41 (2) , 177-191
Abstract
Herein I address and extend the sparse literature on deception in sports, specifically, Kathleen Pearson’s Deception, Sportsmanship, and Ethics and Mark J. Hamilton’s There’s No Lying in Baseball (Wink, Wink). On a Kantian foundation, I argue that attempts to deceive officials, such as framing pitches in baseball, are morally unacceptable because they necessarily regard others (e.g., the umpire) as incompetent and as a mere means to one’s own self-interested ends. More dramatically I argue, contrary to Pearson and Hamilton, that some forms of competitor-to-competitor deception (which Pearson labels ‘strategic deception’) are similarly unacceptable. Specifically, I offer a ‘principle of caustic deceit’ according to which any strategic deception that divorces a game from its constitutive skills is morally untoward and ought to be met with negative social pressure at least, and/or legislated out of existence. The problem with these forms of strategic deception is that they treat one’s opponents, again in the Kantian sense, as a mere means to one’s own self-interested ends.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Caring, final ends and sportsSport, Ethics and Philosophy, 2007
- The Ethics of Strategic Fouling:A Reply to FraleighJournal of the Philosophy of Sport, 2005
- Quoting Baseball: The Intellectual Take on Our National PastimeNINE: A Journal of Baseball History and Culture, 2005
- Intentional Rules Violations—One More TimeJournal of the Philosophy of Sport, 2003
- What Counts As Part of a Game? A Look at SkillsJournal of the Philosophy of Sport, 2000
- Are Rules All an Umpire Has to Work With?Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 1999
- Fair Play as Respect for the GameJournal of the Philosophy of Sport, 1998
- The Concept of a Call in BaseballJournal of the Philosophy of Sport, 1997
- Deception, Sportsmanship, and EthicsQuest, 1973