Abstract
As AI permeates education, adoption, by itself, no longer tells us much about the evolving role the technology plays. To provide new insights, we surveyed 1,444 students in a network of college-preparatory high schools in the United States. We draw from technology management literature and focus on appropriation (i.e., the purposes students assign to AI) and reliance calibration (i.e., the gap between students’ confidence in AI and that in themselves). Regarding appropriation, we found learning-oriented and shortcut-oriented purposes often co-occurred, suggesting that students who asked AI to explain a concept or outline a paper were often the same students who asked it for homework answers or full drafts. This complexity in appropriation challenges the simple dichotomy between “good” and “bad” AI users. In terms of reliance, use frequency was negatively associated with self-confidence without AI and positively associated with reliance calibration, indicating a potentially widening reliance gap. In hierarchical regressions with school-clustered standard errors, use frequency, breadth of purposes, and optimism about AI predicted this gap, while perceived school guidance, surprisingly, did not. Notably, students most often reported receiving general guidelines from schools, but their largest unmet demand was teacher-guided practice. Based on the results, we argue that AI reliance calibration captures the new dynamic relationship between technological capabilities and students’ self-perceptions. Therefore, it should draw the attention from education researchers and schools to understand how AI is used in today’s educational context.

This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit: