“Will they be good enough parents?”: Ethical dilemmas, views, and decisions among assisted reproductive technology (ART) providers
Author:
- 2 October 2017
- journal article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in AJOB Empirical Bioethics
- Vol. 8 (4) , 253-265
Abstract
Many adults may make less-than-ideal parents, but important ethical questions arise concerning whether assisted reproductive technology (ART) providers should thus ever refuse treatment to certain patients, and if so, when, and how to decide. In-depth interviews of approximately 1 hour each were conducted with 27 ART providers (17 physicians, and 10 other health providers). Clinicians often struggle with whether to attempt to assess and predict patients' potential future parenting abilities, and if so, how, and how to proceed if doubts arise. Providers face profound ethical tensions between adults' rights to reproduce and best interests of the eventual children (i.e., to be born into "stable" homes), and questions about the extent of professional responsibilities toward potential parents versus toward future offspring. Providers generally feel uncomfortable with this role, and hence don't want it, partly since they lack training for it, but also because of inherent empirical and ethical uncertainties. Concerns about discrimination based on the mere presence or history of certain diagnoses or traits (e.g., single marital status or past depression) also arise. Clinicians frequently seek to resolve these tensions through various strategies-for example, referring these decisions to others; hoping that patients drop out of treatment; assessing and increasing social support (e.g., arranging for possible co-parents); assisting the patient psychotherapeutically; or seeking to communicate concerns to patients only indirectly or implicitly. Clinics vary in how they make and approach these decisions-whether they rely on a formal ethics or other committee. These data, the first to explore several critical aspects of in vitro fertilization (IVF) providers' views and decision making about assessing the quality of patients' potential future parenting, have critical implications for future practice, education, research, and guidelines. Further empirical and normative scholarship and guidelines are needed to help clarify expectations, processes, and possible approaches to aid providers and patients.Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- Researchers’ views on return of incidental genomic research results: qualitative and quantitative findingsGenetics in Medicine, 2013
- Are the serious problems in cancer survival partly rooted in gatekeeper principles? An ecologic studyBritish Journal of General Practice, 2011
- Committee Opinion No. 480: Empathy in Womenʼs Health CareObstetrics & Gynecology, 2011
- Obstetrician–Gynecologists' Beliefs About Assisted Reproductive TechnologiesObstetrics & Gynecology, 2010
- Retired: Human immunodeficiency virus and infertility treatmentFertility and Sterility, 2010
- Feinberg, Mills, and the Child's Right to an Open FutureJournal of Social Philosophy, 2006
- How Many Interviews Are Enough?Field Methods, 2006
- Screening practices and beliefs of assisted reproductive technology programsFertility and Sterility, 2005
- Mothers' personality and its interaction with child temperament as predictors of parenting behavior.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2000
- issues in clinical assessment of minimal parenting competenceJournal of Clinical Child Psychology, 1996