Antibody Titers in Transfusion Medicine: A Critical Reevaluation of Testing Accuracy, Reliability, and Clinical Use
Open Access
- 2 February 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Archives of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine in Archives of Pathology & Laboratory Medicine
- Vol. 147 (12) , 1351-1359
Abstract
Context.—: Substantial variability between different antibody titration methods has been identified since the development and introduction of the uniform procedure in 2008. Objective.—: To determine whether more recent methods or techniques decrease interlaboratory and intralaboratory variation measured using proficiency testing. Design.—: Proficiency test data for antibody titration between 2014 and 2018 were obtained from the College of American Pathologists. Interlaboratory and intralaboratory variations were compared by analyzing the distribution of titer results by method and phase, comparing the results against the supplier’s quality control titer, and by evaluating the distribution of paired titer results when each laboratory received a sample with the same titer twice. Results.—: A total of 1337 laboratories participated in the antibody titer proficiency test during the study period. Only 54.1% (5874 of 10 852) of anti-D and 63.4% (3603 of 5680) of anti-A reported responses were within 1 titer of the supplier’s intended result. Review of the agreement between laboratories of the same methodology found that 78.4% (3139 of 4004) for anti-A and 89.0% (9655 of 10 852) of laboratory responses for anti-D fell within 1 titer of the mode response. When provided with 2 consecutive samples of the same titer (anti-D titer: 16), 85% (367 of 434) of laboratories using the uniform procedure and 80% (458 of 576) using the other method reported a titer difference of 1 or less. Conclusions.—: Despite advances, interlaboratory and intralaboratory variance for this assay remains high in comparison with the strong reliance on titer results in clinical practice. There needs to be a reevaluation of the role of this test in clinical decision-making.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- A practical strategy to reduce the risk of passive hemolysis by screening plateletpheresis donors for high‐titer ABO antibodiesTransfusion, 2011
- IMMUNOHEMATOLOGY: Streamlining ABO antibody titrations for monitoring ABO‐incompatible kidney transplantsTransfusion, 2010
- The critical role of plasmapheresis in ABO‐incompatible renal transplantationTransfusion, 2008
- Interinstitutional Variation in the Measurement of Anti-A/B Antibodies: The Japanese ABO-Incompatible Transplantation Committee SurveyTransplantation, 2007
- Flow Cytometric Measurement of ABO Antibodies in ABO-Incompatible Living Donor Kidney TransplantationTransplantation, 2007
- Comparing the Tube and Gel Techniques for ABO Antibody Titration, as Performed in Three European CentersTransplantation, 2007
- Comparison of three microtube column agglutination systems for antibody screening: DG Gel, DiaMed‐ID and Ortho BioVueTransfusion Medicine, 2006
- Isotype‐specific detection of ABO blood group antibodies using a novel flow cytometric methodBritish Journal of Haematology, 2005
- Implementation of Gel Testing for Antibody Screening and Identification in a Community Hospital, a 3-Year ExperienceLaboratory Medicine, 2005
- Prenatal and perinatal immunohematology: recommendations for serologic management of the fetus, newborn infant, and obstetric patientTransfusion, 1990