Fictions of Intention in the “Cultural Defense”
- 17 December 2008
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in American Anthropologist
- Vol. 110 (4) , 432-442
Abstract
ABSTRACT The “cultural defense” in criminal law presents anthropologists with an instance of culture being used as a particular sort of tool, in this case, a tool for revealing the intentions of a defendant. In deploying culture instrumentally, courts in the United States and the United Kingdom constitute their other instruments and indeed their own environments as noncultural. By comparison, courts in Papua New Guinea do not use culture as a means of discovering intentions; indeed, it can be argued that although “custom” is enshrined in the Constitutional law of the country, “culture” hardly appears at all in Papua New Guinean arguments. Case material from the three legal settings illustrates that far from offering a recognition of culture, the cultural defense acts to limit the culture concept to the status of one diagnostic mechanism among other, noncultural ones.Keywords
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Debate. Culture in the nation and public opinion: a Norwegian case Culture: A new concept of raceSocial Anthropology/Anthropologie Sociale, 2007
- Negotiating the Boundaries of Crime and Culture: A Sociolegal Perspective on Cultural Defense StrategiesLaw & Social Inquiry, 2003
- Temporarily insane: pathologising cultural difference in American criminal courtsSociology of Health & Illness, 2002
- Bargains with modernity in Papua New Guinea and elsewhereAnthropological Theory, 2002
- Women, Justice, and Custom: the Discourse of "Good Custom" and "Bad Custom" in Papua New Guinea and CanadaInternational Journal of Comparative Sociology, 2001
- Culture as CureCultural Anthropology, 1996
- The Cultural Defense: Beyond Exclusion, Assimilation, and Guilty LiberalismCalifornia Law Review, 1994
- What Is to Be Gained by Looking White People in the Eye? Culture, Race, and Gender in Cases of Sexual ViolenceSigns: Journal of Women in Culture and Society, 1994
- Legal Adaptation in a Papua New Guinea Village CourtEthnology, 1990
- Court Is an Arrow: Legal Pluralism in Papua New GuineaEthnology, 1986