The Resilience of Pandemic Digital Deliberation: An Analysis of Online Synchronous Forums
Authors:
- Stephen ElstubSEStephen Elstub
- Rachel ThompsonRTRachel Thompson
- Oliver EscobarOEOliver Escobar
- Joe HollinghurstJHJoe Hollinghurst
- Duncan GrimesDGDuncan Grimes
- Mhairi AitkenMAMhairi Aitken
- Anna McKeonAMAnna McKeon
- Kerina H. JonesKJKerina H. Jones
- Alexa WaudAWAlexa Waud
- Nayha SethiNSNayha Sethi
Open Access
- 3 July 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Javnost - The Public
- Vol. 28 (3) , 237-255
Abstract
Quality deliberation is essential for societies to address the challenges presented by the coronavirus pandemic effectively and legitimately. Critics of deliberative and participatory democracy are highly skeptical that most citizens can engage with such complex issues in good circumstances and these are far from ideal circumstances. The need for rapid action and decision-making is a challenge for inclusivity and quality of deliberation. Additionally, policy responses to the virus need to be even more co-ordinated than usual, which intensifies their complexity. The digitalisation of the public sphere may be seen as a further challenge to deliberating. Furthermore, these are stressful and emotional times, making a considered judgement on these issues potentially challenging. We employ a modified version of the Discourse Quality Index to assess the deliberative quality in two facilitated synchronous digital platforms to consider aspects of data use in light of COVID 19. Our study is the first to perform a comprehensive, systematic and in-depth analysis of the deliberative capacity of citizens in a pandemic. Our evidence indicates that deliberation can be resilient in a crisis. The findings will have relevance to those interested in pandemic democracy, deliberative democracy in a crisis, data use and digital public spheres.Keywords
Funding Information
- Administrative Data Research UK (ADR) UK
- Wales Co-Production Network
- HealthWise Wales
- Digital Inclusion Alliance Wales
- Traverse
- Ada Lovelace Institute
- Bang the Table and Involve
This publication has 49 references indexed in Scilit:
- Deliberative Capacity in the Political and Civic SphereSwiss Political Science Review, 2014
- Online Deliberation Design2012
- Democratic Reason2012
- Design Considerations for Online Deliberation SystemsJournal of Information Technology & Politics, 2012
- Online versus face-to-face deliberation: Who? Why? What? With what effects?New Media & Society, 2011
- Suspending Disbelief2011
- On the Applicability of the Most Similar Systems Design and the Most Different Systems Design in Comparative ResearchInternational Journal of Social Research Methodology, 2008
- Democracy, deliberation and design: the case of online discussion forumsNew Media & Society, 2007
- A Tale of Two Cultures: Contrasting Quantitative and Qualitative ResearchPolitical Analysis, 2006
- Measuring Political Deliberation: A Discourse Quality IndexComparative European Politics, 2003