Large variation in participant eligibility criteria used in plantar heel pain research studies ‐ a systematic review
Authors:
- Henrik RielHRHenrik Riel
- Melanie Louise PlinsingaMPMelanie Louise Plinsinga
- Eamonn DelahuntEDEamonn Delahunt
- Martin Bach JensenMJMartin Bach Jensen
- Karl B. LandorfKLKarl B. Landorf
- Marienke van MiddelkoopMMMarienke van Middelkoop
- Edward RoddyEREdward Roddy
- Michael Skovdal RathleffMRMichael Skovdal Rathleff
- Bill VicenzinoBVBill Vicenzino
- Jens Lykkegaard OlesenJOJens Lykkegaard Olesen
Open Access
- 9 September 2022
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Foot and Ankle Research
- Vol. 15 (1) , 1-8
Abstract
Introduction: Variable eligibility criteria across studies on plantar heel pain may result in compromising the generalisability of meta‐analyses when heterogeneity is not accounted for. We aimed to explore: (i) heterogeneity of participant eligibility criteria in studies that have investigated plantar heel pain, and (ii) associations between key eligibility criteria and the characteristics of the participants included in the study.Methods: In this systematic review with narrative synthesis, we extracted participant eligibility criteria, and participants' age, body mass index (BMI), symptom duration and pain level from published studies on plantar heel pain. We performed a content analysis of criteria and aligned overarching criteria to the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF). We pooled studies that used the same thresholds for participant eligibility criteria into sub‐groups. We also pooled and reported studies that did not have any eligibility criteria for the quantitative characteristics to use their data for reference values and pooled studies that did not have any eligibility criteria for the characteristics as reference.Results: Two hundred and fourteen articles were included. The most reported participant eligibility criteria (as aligned to the ICF) related to body structures/function and personal factors. Age, BMI, symptom duration and pain level were used with various ranges and/or thresholds across studies (age was reported in 23 different ways across 97 studies; BMI 7/13; symptom duration 14/100; and pain level 8/31). When eligibility criteria included thresholds close to the reference value of a participant characteristic, characteristics were associated with criteria (e.g., younger participants when an upper age threshold was used).Conclusion: Participant eligibility criteria in studies on plantar heel pain vary widely; studies differed substantially in their use of quantitative thresholds. Participant characteristics of samples in studies were associated with the criteria used. This study emphasises a need for adjusting for participant heterogeneity in systematic reviews to improve their validity.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Systematic review: plantar fasciitis and prolonged weight bearingOccupational Medicine, 2015
- Estimating the sample mean and standard deviation from the sample size, median, range and/or interquartile rangeBMC Medical Research Methodology, 2014
- Predictors of Response to Physical Therapy Intervention for Plantar Heel PainFoot & Ankle International, 2014
- Heel Pain—Plantar Fasciitis: Revision 2014Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy, 2014
- Investigating clinical heterogeneity in systematic reviews: a methodologic review of guidance in the literatureBMC Medical Research Methodology, 2012
- Variation in Eligibility Criteria From Studies of Radiculopathy due to a Herniated Disc and of Neurogenic Claudication due to Lumbar Spinal StenosisSpine, 2010
- Assessing Risk of Bias in Included Studies2008
- Development of classification and response criteria for rheumatic diseasesArthritis Care & Research, 2006
- Measuring inconsistency in meta-analysesBMJ, 2003
- A retrospective case-control analysis of 2002 running injuriesBritish Journal of Sports Medicine, 2002