Avatar Therapy for people with schizophrenia or related disorders
Authors:
- 8 May 2020
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews
- Vol. 2020 (5) , CD011898
Abstract
Background Many people with schizophrenia do not achieve satisfactory improvements in their mental state, particularly the symptom of hearing voices (hallucinations), with medical treatment. Objectives To examine the effects of Avatar Therapy for people with schizophrenia or related disorders. Search methods In December 2016, November 2018 and April 2019, the Cochrane Schizophrenia Group's Study‐Based Register of Trials (including registries of clinical trials) was searched, review authors checked references of all identified relevant reports to identify more studies and contacted authors of trials for additional information. Selection criteria All randomised clinical trials focusing on Avatar Therapy for people with schizophrenia or related disorders. Data collection and analysis We extracted data independently. For binary outcomes, we calculated risk ratio (RR) and 95% confidence intervals (CI), on an intention‐to‐treat basis. For continuous data, we estimated the mean difference (MD) between groups and 95% CIs. We employed a fixed‐effect model for analyses. We assessed risk of bias for included studies and created 'Summary of findings' tables using GRADE. Our main outcomes of interest were clinically important change in; mental state, insight, global state, quality of life and functioning as well as adverse effects and leaving the study early. Main results We found 14 potentially relevant references for three studies (participants = 195) comparing Avatar Therapy with two other interventions; treatment as usual or supportive counselling. Both Avatar Therapy and supportive counselling were given in addition (add‐on) to the participants' normal care. All of the studies had high risk of bias across one or more domains for methodology and, for other risks of bias, authors from one of the studies were involved in the development of the avatar systems on trial and in another trial, authors had patents on the avatar system pending. 1. Avatar Therapy compared with treatment as usual When Avatar Therapy was compared with treatment as usual average endpoint Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale – Positive (PANSS‐P) scores were not different between treatment groups (MD –1.93, 95% CI –5.10 to 1.24; studies = 1, participants = 19; very low‐certainty evidence). A measure of insight (Revised Beliefs about Voices Questionnaire; BAVQ‐R) showed an effect in favour of Avatar Therapy (MD –5.97, 95% CI –10.98 to –0.96; studies = 1, participants = 19; very low‐certainty evidence). No one was rehospitalised in either group in the short term (risk difference (RD) 0.00, 95% CI –0.20 to 0.20; studies = 1, participants = 19; low‐certainty evidence). Numbers leaving the study early from each group were not clearly different – although more did leave from the Avatar Therapy group (6/14 versus 0/12; RR 11.27, 95% CI 0.70 to 181.41; studies = 1, participants = 26; low‐certainty evidence). There was no clear difference in anxiety between treatment groups (RR 5.54, 95% CI 0.34 to 89.80; studies = 1, participants = 19; low‐certainty evidence). For quality of life, average Quality of Life Enjoyment and Satisfaction Questionnaire‐Short Form (QLESQ‐SF) scores favoured Avatar Therapy (MD 9.99, 95% CI 3.89 to 16.09; studies = 1, participants = 19; very low‐certainty evidence). No study reported data for functioning. 2. Avatar Therapy compared with supportive counselling When Avatar Therapy was compared with supportive counselling (all short‐term), general mental state (Psychotic Symptom Rating Scale (PSYRATS)) scores favoured the Avatar Therapy group (MD –4.74, 95% CI –8.01 to –1.47; studies = 1, participants = 124; low‐certainty evidence). For insight (BAVQ‐R), there was a small effect in favour of Avatar Therapy (MD –8.39, 95% CI –14.31 to –2.47; studies = 1, participants = 124; low‐certainty evidence). Around 20% of each group left the study early (risk ratio (RR) 1.06, 95% CI 0.59 to 1.89; studies = 1, participants = 150; moderate‐certainty evidence). Analysis of quality of life scores (Manchester Short Assessment of Quality of Life (MANSA)) showed no clear difference between groups (MD 2.69, 95% CI –1.48 to 6.86; studies = 1, participants = 120; low‐certainty evidence). No data were available for rehospitalisation rates, adverse events or functioning. Authors' conclusions Our analyses of available data shows few, if any, consistent effects of Avatar Therapy for people living with schizophrenia who experience auditory hallucinations. Where there are effects, or suggestions of effects, we are uncertain because of their risk of bias and their unclear clinical meaning. The theory behind Avatar Therapy is compelling but the practice needs testing in large, long, well‐designed, well‐reported randomised trials undertaken with help from – but not under the direction of – Avatar Therapy pioneers.Keywords
This publication has 47 references indexed in Scilit:
- Computer-assisted therapy for medication-resistant auditory hallucinations: proof-of-concept studyThe British Journal of Psychiatry, 2013
- Avatar therapy for persecutory auditory hallucinations: What is it and how does it work?Psychosis, 2013
- Assessing health-related quality of life in generalized anxiety disorder using the Quality Of Life Enjoyment and Satisfaction QuestionnaireInternational Clinical Psychopharmacology, 2009
- Losing participants before the trial ends erodes credibility of findingsPsychiatric Bulletin, 2009
- Number needed to treat and number needed to harm are not the best way to report and assess the results of randomised clinical trialsBritish Journal of Haematology, 2009
- Clinical implications of Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale scoresThe British Journal of Psychiatry, 2005
- The short‐form version of the Depression Anxiety Stress Scales (DASS‐21): Construct validity and normative data in a large non‐clinical sampleBritish Journal of Clinical Psychology, 2005
- Quality-of-Life Impairment in Depressive and Anxiety DisordersAmerican Journal of Psychiatry, 2005
- A Systematic Review of the Prevalence of SchizophreniaPLOS Medicine, 2005
- Measuring inconsistency in meta-analysesBMJ, 2003