The Development of Metallurgy in Southeast Asia: Reply to Loofs-Wissowa
Authors:
- Donn BayardDBDonn Bayard
- Pisit CharoenwongsaPCPisit Charoenwongsa
- 7 April 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Duke University Press in Journal of Southeast Asian Studies
- Vol. 14 (1) , 12-17
Abstract
We find this a most curious attack, both in tone and in substance; Loofs-Wissowa appears to believe that we, Solheim, Gorman, and the media have been engaged in a conspiracy to cloud the minds of Westerners and Southeast Asians alike on the origins of metallurgy in the region. Loofs-Wissowa evidently feels that Southeast Asian laymen view this question as equal in importance to contemporary issues there (which is of course not the case). He also believes that it is the most burning issue in archaeology since Piltdown or Glozel, splitting the profession into “Believers” in the “long dates” and “Non Believers”. This is again rather an exaggeration; we would estimate the “Believers” to number not more than a few hundred, while the “Non Believers” may be counted on the fingers of one hand (Marschall, Sørensen, Sieveking, and of course Loofs-Wissowa himself). The remainder of the archaeological world (i.e., over 90%) has other questions to occupy it. However, Loofs-Wissowa is certainly correct in pointing out the attention paid to the question of early metallurgy over the past few years, and we welcome this opportunity to counter his arguments and distinguish between our views and those published by the media. This may best be done by first pointing out errors of omission in the facts presented by Loofs-Wissowa, by examining basic errors in his conceptual framework, and finally by answering the three specific questions he poses.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Roots of Indochinese Civilisation: Recent Developments in the Prehistory of Southeast AsiaPacific Affairs, 1980
- Origins of Agriculture1977
- The Beginnings of Metallurgy: A New LookScience, 1973
- The problem of tin in the ancient world: A reply to Dr Muhly and Dr WertimeWorld Archaeology, 1973
- Evidence for the sources and use of tin during the Bronze Age of the Near East: A reply to J. E. DaytonWorld Archaeology, 1973
- Early Thai Bronze: Analysis and New DatesScience, 1972
- Studies in ancient technology1972
- The Autonomy of the South-East European Copper AgeProceedings of the Prehistoric Society, 1970