Usability of Health Care Price Transparency Data in the United States: Mixed Methods Study (Preprint)
Preprint
- 7 July 2023
- preprint
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Abstract
BACKGROUND Increasing health care expenditure in the United States has put policy makers under enormous pressure to find ways to curtail costs. Starting January 1, 2021, hospitals operating in the United States were mandated to publish transparent, accessible pricing information online about the items and services in a consumer-friendly format within comprehensive machine-readable files on their websites. OBJECTIVE The aims of this study are to analyze the available files on hospitals’ websites, answering the question—is price transparency (PT) information as provided usable for patients or for machines?—and to provide a solution. METHODS We analyzed 39 main hospitals in Florida that have published machine-readable files on their website, including commercial carriers. We created an Excel (Microsoft) file that included those 39 hospitals along with the 4 most popular services—Current Procedural Terminology (CPT) 45380, 29827, and 70553 and Diagnosis-Related Group (DRG) 807—for the 4 most popular commercial carriers (Health Maintenance Organization [HMO] or Preferred Provider Organization [PPO] plans)—Aetna, Florida Blue, Cigna, and UnitedHealthcare. We conducted an A/B test using 67 MTurkers (randomly selected from US residents), investigating the level of awareness about PT legislation and the usability of available files. We also suggested format standardization, such as master field names using schema integration, to make machine-readable files consistent and usable for machines. RESULTS The poor usability and inconsistent formats of the current PT information yielded no evidence of its usefulness for patients or its quality for machines. This indicates that the information does not meet the requirements for being consumer-friendly or machine readable as mandated by legislation. Based on the responses to the first part of the experiment (PT awareness), it was evident that participants need to be made aware of the PT legislation. However, they believe it is important to know the service price before receiving it. Based on the responses to the second part of the experiment (human usability of PT information), the average number of correct responses was not equal between the 2 groups, that is, the treatment group (mean 1.23, SD 1.30) found more correct answers than the control group (mean 2.76, SD 0.58; t65=6.46; P<.001; d=1.52). CONCLUSIONS Consistent machine-readable files across all health systems facilitate the development of tools for estimating customer out-of-pocket costs, aligning with the PT rule’s main objective—providing patients with valuable information and reducing health care expenditures.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: Journal of Medical Internet Research, 26, e50629.
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Mystery Of The Chargemaster: Examining The Role Of Hospital List Prices In What Patients Actually PayHealth Affairs, 2017
- Association Between Viewing Health Care Price Information and Choice of Health Care FacilityJAMA Internal Medicine, 2016
- Association Between Availability of a Price Transparency Tool and Outpatient SpendingJAMA, 2016
- Examining A Health Care Price Transparency Tool: Who Uses It, And How They Shop For CareHealth Affairs, 2016
- Health Care Price Transparency and Economic TheoryJAMA, 2014
- Price Transparency For MRIs Increased Use Of Less Costly Providers And Triggered Provider CompetitionHealth Affairs, 2014
- Use Patterns of a State Health Care Price Transparency Web SiteINQUIRY: The Journal of Health Care Organization, Provision, and Financing, 2014
- Limited Use of Price and Quality Advertising Among American HospitalsJournal of Medical Internet Research, 2013
- Clarifying Costs: Can Increased Price Transparency Reduce Healthcare Spending?SSRN Electronic Journal, 2013
- A comparative analysis of methodologies for database schema integrationACM Computing Surveys, 1986