Analysis of the logic and framing of a tobacco industry campaign opposing standardised packaging legislation in New Zealand
- 30 September 2016
- journal article
- Published by BMJ in Tobacco Control
- Vol. 26 (6) , 629-633
Abstract
Background The tobacco industry routinely opposes tobacco control policies, often using a standard repertoire of arguments. Following proposals to introduce standardised packaging in New Zealand (NZ), British American Tobacco New Zealand (BATNZ) launched the ‘Agree–Disagree’ mass media campaign, which coincided with the NZ government's standardised packaging consultations. This study examined the logic of the arguments presented and rhetorical strategies employed in the campaign. Methods We analysed each advertisement to identify key messages, arguments and rhetorical devices, then examined the arguments' structure and assessed their logical soundness and validity. Results All advertisements attempted to frame BATNZ as reasonable, and each contained flawed arguments that were either unsound or based on logical fallacies. Flawed arguments included misrepresenting the intent of the proposed legislation (straw man), claiming standardised packaging would harm all NZ brands (false dilemma), warning NZ not to adopt standardised packaging because of its Australian origins (an unsound argument) or using vague premises as a basis for claiming negative outcomes (equivocation). Conclusions BATNZ's Agree–Disagree campaign relied on unsound arguments, logical fallacies and rhetorical devices. Given the industry's frequent recourse to these tactics, we propose strategies based on our study findings that can be used to assist the tobacco control community to counter industry opposition to standardised packaging. Greater recognition of logical fallacies and rhetorical devices employed by the tobacco industry will help maintain focus on the health benefits proposed policies will deliver.Keywords
Funding Information
- University of Otago (These grants do not have a number)
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Framing and the health policy process: a scoping reviewHealth Policy and Planning, 2016
- How Does the Tobacco Industry Attempt to Influence Marketing Regulations? A Systematic ReviewPLOS ONE, 2014
- A critical evaluation of the volume, relevance and quality of evidence submitted by the tobacco industry to oppose standardised packaging of tobacco productsBMJ Open, 2014
- The Possibility and Actuality of Visual Arguments2011
- Young Adults’ Interpretations of Tobacco Brands: Implications for Tobacco ControlNicotine & Tobacco Research, 2011
- “Avoid health warnings on all tobacco products for just as long as we can”: a history of Australian tobacco industry efforts to avoid, delay and dilute health warnings on cigarettesTobacco Control, 2003
- Review of the quality of studies on the economic effects of smoke-free policies on the hospitality industryTobacco Control, 2003
- Informal Logic2001
- Tobacco Advertising and Consumption: Evidence of a Causal RelationshipJournal of Public Health Policy, 1987