Discussion Sections in Reports of Controlled Trials Published in General Medical Journals
Authors:
- Mike ClarkeMCMike Clarke
- Phil AldersonPAPhil Alderson
- Iain ChalmersICIain Chalmers
Open Access
- 5 June 2002
- journal article
- quality issues-and-standards
- Published by American Medical Association (AMA) in JAMA
- Vol. 287 (21) , 2799-2801
Abstract
ContextReliable interpretation of the results of a controlled trial entails setting its results in the context of similar research. A previous study showed that most reports of controlled trials published in 5 general medical journals in May 1997 were deficient in this respect. We assessed the extent to which reports of controlled trials published in the same 5 journals discussed new results in light of the totality of evidence from other controlled trials.MethodsAssessment of the discussion sections in all 33 reports of randomized trials published during May 2001 in Annals of Internal Medicine, BMJ, JAMA, The Lancet, and The New England Journal of Medicine.ResultsThree reports appeared to have been the first published trials to address the questions studied. In none of the remaining 30 reports were the results of the new trial discussed in the context of an updated systematic review of other trials. Although reference was made to relevant systematic reviews in 3 of these 30 reports, there was no integration, quantitative or qualitative, of the results of the new trials in an update of these reviews. In the remaining 27 reports, there was no evidence that any systematic attempt had been made to set the new results in the context of previous trials.ConclusionsBetween 1997 and 2001, there was no evidence of progress in the proportion of reports of trials published in general medical journals that discussed the new results within the context of, or with reference to, up-to-date systematic reviews of relevant evidence from other controlled trials.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Inhaled Corticosteroid Reduction and Elimination in Patients With Persistent Asthma Receiving SalmeterolA Randomized Controlled TrialJAMA, 2001
- Long-Acting β2-Agonist Monotherapy vs Continued Therapy With Inhaled Corticosteroids in Patients With Persistent AsthmaA Randomized Controlled TrialJAMA, 2001
- Evaluation of Contraceptive Efficacy and Cycle Control of a Transdermal Contraceptive Patch vs an Oral ContraceptiveA Randomized Controlled TrialJAMA, 2001
- WHO antenatal care randomised trial for the evaluation of a new model of routine antenatal careThe Lancet, 2001
- Effect of audit and feedback, and reminder messages on primary-care radiology referrals: a randomised trialThe Lancet, 2001
- WHO systematic review of randomised controlled trials of routine antenatal careThe Lancet, 2001
- The CONSORT statement: revised recommendations for improving the quality of reports of parallel-group randomised trialsThe Lancet, 2001
- The function of the discussion section in academic medical writingBMJ, 2000
- How can medical journals help prevent poor medical research? Some opportunities presented by electronic publishingThe Lancet, 1999
- Improving the quality of reporting of randomized controlled trials. The CONSORT statementJAMA, 1996