A formal analysis of some factor- and precedent-based accounts of precedential constraint
Author:
Open Access
- 23 February 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Artificial Intelligence and Law
- Vol. 29 (4) , 559-585
Abstract
In this paper several recent factor- and dimension-based models of precedential constraint are formally investigated and an alternative dimension-based model is proposed. Simple factor- and dimension-based syntactic criteria are identified for checking whether a decision in a new case is forced, in terms of the relevant differences between a precedent and a new case, and the difference between absence of factors and negated factors in factor-based models is investigated. Then Horty’s and Rigoni’s recent dimension-based models of precedential constraint are critically examined. An alternative to their reason models is proposed which is less expressive but arguably easier to apply in practice.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Representing dimensions within the reason model of precedentArtificial Intelligence and Law, 2017
- Reasoning with dimensions and magnitudes2017
- An improved factor based approach to precedential constraintArtificial Intelligence and Law, 2015
- A factor-based definition of precedential constraintArtificial Intelligence and Law, 2012
- RULES AND REASONS IN THE THEORY OF PRECEDENTLegal Theory, 2011
- Some observations on modelling case based reasoning with formal argument models1999
- Monological reason-based logic1993
- A design for reasoning with policies, precedents, and rationales1993
- Toward a computational theory of arguing with precedents1989
- A case-based system for trade secrets law1987