Certifications systems as independent and rigorous tools for assessing urban sustainability
Authors:
- 7 November 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Urban Sciences
- Vol. 22 (3) , 308-321
Abstract
Urban sustainability certification (USC) systems are witnessing a wide dissemination and some are used as globally relevant tools. In addition, USCs are being marketed as independent tools capable of assessing sustainability not only comprehensively but also using rigorous measures. The comprehensiveness and rigour of their assessment rest on a combination of simple criteria (directly prescribing indicators with quantitative/qualitative measures) and nested ones (hosting other references for sustainable planning (RsSP)) prescribed within each USC. However, such scope seems over-ambitious due to the complexity of urban sustainability and its contextual sensitivity. Accordingly, this study aims to delve in USCs and examine their rigour and independence. The study begins by analyzing the concepts of street connectivity and compactness in LEED-ND (the most rigorous USC) because both are prominent concepts and have a number of earmarked criteria with simple structure. Then, criteria with nested structure and their RsSP found in four USCs are collected and analyzed in terms of frequencies, weights, and geographic domains. This analysis aims to uncover how dependent USCs are on other RsSP and how compatible are the geographic domains of both. The results refute the rigour of LEED-ND's assessment in terms of compactness and connectivity because the prescribed measures are insufficient to assess the different variables of both concepts. Moreover, USCs are highly dependent on local RsSP (only relevant to USC's country of origin), which disagrees with their characterization as independent or international tools.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Sustainable transportation according to certification systems: A viability analysis based on neighborhood size and context relevanceEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review, 2017
- Sustainability on the urban scale: Proposal of a structure of indicators for the Spanish contextEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review, 2015
- Do green neighbourhood ratings cover sustainability?Ecological Indicators, 2015
- The structure of the green certification scheme for the neighbourhood and application to the new town development: the case of Magok, Seoul, KoreaInternational Journal of Urban Sciences, 2014
- Sustainability indicator systems within urban governance: Usability analysis of sustainability indicator systems as boundary objectsEcological Indicators, 2013
- Sustainability assessment: the state of the artImpact Assessment and Project Appraisal, 2012
- Towards sustainable urban communitiesEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review, 2012
- Urban sustainability standards: predetermined checklists or adaptable frameworks?Procedia Engineering, 2011
- Neighborhood, Route, and School Environments and Children's Active CommutingAmerican Journal of Preventive Medicine, 2010
- The Compact City FallacyJournal of Planning Education and Research, 2005