The impact of uncertainty on disclosure of prenatal exome sequencing results: A vignette study among medical students
Open Access
- 14 May 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 21 (5) , e0349014
Abstract
Introduction: We recruited medical students for a study to investigate how they make decisions regarding which hypothetical genetic results to report during pregnancy. We tested how medical students as healthcare professionals handled uncertain prenatal Exome Sequencing results, and whether intolerance of uncertainty (IU) influenced decisions to share results with prospective parents. Exploring the impact of uncertainty on important medical decisions can help optimize counselling. Materials and methods: Fifty-one participants ranked vignettes covering several types of uncertain prenatal ES results on perceived uncertainty. Participants answered whether they would report each result to the theoretical couple and indicated how certain they were about their choice. Additionally, their IU was measured using the Intolerance of Uncertainty Scale (IUS) and results were compared between low IU and high IU to test whether this influenced the results. The role of termination of pregnancy (TOP) considerations on these variables and experienced anxiety was also explored. Results: Participants reported fewer highly uncertain results than results low in uncertainty. Participants were more uncertain about their choices to report with highly uncertain results than results low in uncertainty. IU did not influence these relationships. Anxiety of the students when parents considered TOP was not correlated with number of reported results nor certainty with these reporting choices. Conclusions: In this study we validated the widespread hypothesis that the willingness to convey uncertain prenatal ES results decreased as uncertainty increased. This willingness did not seem to be higher or lower when taking into account IU. More research among experienced healthcare professionals is needed to ascertain whether findings from this study extend to real-life decision-making.Keywords
This publication has 40 references indexed in Scilit:
- Diagnostic yield of exome sequencing for prenatal diagnosis of fetal structural anomalies: A systematic review and meta‐analysisPrenatal Diagnosis, 2022
- Dealing with uncertain results from chromosomal microarray and exome sequencing in the prenatal setting: An international cross‐sectional study with healthcare professionalsPrenatal Diagnosis, 2021
- How do geneticists and prospective parents interpret and negotiate an uncertain prenatal genetic result? An analysis of clinical interactionsJournal of Genetic Counseling, 2020
- Choosing between Higher and Lower Resolution Microarrays: do Pregnant Women Have Sufficient Knowledge to Make Informed Choices Consistent with their Attitude?Journal of Genetic Counseling, 2017
- Prenatal DNA Sequencing: Clinical, Counseling, and Diagnostic Laboratory ConsiderationsPrenatal Diagnosis, 2017
- Prenatal whole exome sequencing: the views of clinicians, scientists, genetic counsellors and patient representativesPrenatal Diagnosis, 2016
- A first look at women's perspectives on noninvasive prenatal testing to detect sex chromosome aneuploidies and microdeletion syndromesPrenatal Diagnosis, 2015
- Current controversies in prenatal diagnosis 2: should incidental findings arising from prenatal testing always be reported to patients?Prenatal Diagnosis, 2013
- “If it helps …” the use of microarray technology in prenatal testing: Patient and partners reflectionsAmerican Journal of Medical Genetics Part A, 2013
- A Closer Look at the Recommended Criteria for Disclosing Genetic Results: Perspectives of Medical Genetic Specialists, Genomic Researchers, and Institutional Review Board ChairsJournal of Genetic Counseling, 2013